awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

A Good Neighborhood by Therese Anne Fowler
3.0

I'm really torn about how to rate this book. The plot is captivating and enticing. I got into the middle of it and was hooked. I needed to continue to see what happened and how everything played out. And while I guessed what was going to happen before it did, I was still interested in watching it play out.

While I think the plot was the strong point in the book, I think Therese Fowler really dropped the ball when it came to her characters. She introduces the book through the point of view of the nameless neighbors, the "we" she refers to multiple times in the book, and while I think this is a really interesting way to step back at times and take a neutral stance on what's going on, I think it could have been done better. It felt random and didn't really add anything additional to the story line or characters. I think had Fowler committed and written the entire book in this way it would have felt more intentional and had a purpose. But the author adds this in while jumping to Juniper's, Brad's, Julie's, Xavier's and Valerie's POV which just causes it to become yet another voice in the story.

Folwer relies on telling the reader how the characters feel rather than showing you. The story revolves around Xavier and Junipers relationship, but a lot of the story glosses over it. Time moves on as you switch POVs so at one moment they're having their first kiss, then months later they're working together and discussing that they could date and then all of sudden they're in love. Fowler leaves it up to you to just trust that they feel this way, rather than showing you how in love these characters are. Fowler is trying to move the story forward in time while also showing you everyone's different perspectives. She has to leave some of those details out which unfortunately makes her characters feel a little flat.

I know it seems like I have a lot of bad things to say about this book, but those are really the only major problems I saw. The plot is captivating and while I think she could have fleshed out the characters a little more, it in no way took away from the book. I truly enjoyed the read and like where and how Fowler took the story. I loved how she talked about the trees and used them for symbolism throughout the entire book. She's a great writer and the story was a joy to read. She did a stunning job of pulling me in, ripping out my heart, and stomping all over it in the best way possible. In a way you want a book too. The book has a lot of important messages and it seemed like she really did her research. (But please, if this is incorrect let me know.)