I have read Fourth Wing twice previously. This was my first time with the graphic audio. I can't decide if I love or hate graphic audios. I really liked how they add music and sound effects to round out the reading experience. However there are part that I really did not need sound effects for...specifically the romancy parts. While I love reading romancy parts and I don't mind listening to people read romancy parts...I don't know if I need sound effects in my ears. Otherwise this was a fun new way to experience the fourth wing story in a new way.