remingtonjill's profile picture

remingtonjill 's review for:

Immortal by Sue Lynn Tan
2.0
adventurous dark fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

 Although this audiobook was not for me, there are a few positive things I would like to note. Natalie Naudus is a wonderful narrator, and I always enjoy listening to her. She is talented and conveys emotion very well. I tend to lean towards fantasy stories in the first person, so that helped me get into the book more easily at the beginning. The plot is an interesting concept. The visuals were also vibrant, so I did enjoy how they painted the picture of a beautiful world for me to imagine.

Unfortunately, I have more critical notes that I will list out below. I would have DNF'd this audiobook if I did not receive it as an ARC generously provided by the publisher.

Pacing:
The beginning of the book felt slow. I got the idea that the intention was to set up the world and draw the reader to Liyen, but I did not find myself invested in her story or liking her character. It also failed to set up the stakes or show me what the journey might look like for her. Later on in the book, I continued to struggle with the pacing. Characters would encounter a problem or decide to do something, then it would just be resolved easily and they would move on. There wasn't much delayed gratification that kept me wanting to see what would happen next. High stakes scenes were happening in rapid succession at the end of the book, and each scene felt like it should be a culmination or final showdown, but then more and more of them kept happening, which made me lose interest. 

Characters and relationship development:
I found Liyen to be immature and lacking complexity. I'm not sure if her indignant attitude was intentional, but it did not draw me to her. When it came to the leadership of her people and her relationship with the immortals, she seemed to be ruled by emotion and spite. Her relationship with Zhangwei (even after the plot twist) felt very surface-level and perplexing to me. I could not see what drew them to one another, which made their bold claims of devotion feel inauthentic. Her initial disdain for the God of War felt very heavy-handed and overstated. The conversations between Zhangwei and Liyen felt like they were supposed to come across as witty banter, but for me it was just bickering that did not add to their story and made their relationship development take steps backward. About three quarters of the way through the book I felt like finally I cared about the characters slightly more, but not enough to make it an enjoyable read for me.

The Writing
I was surprised to learn that this was not the author's debut novel. The writing overall felt very plain to me and lacked nuance to the level that I believe it may be better suited for a juvenile level reader (minus the more adult themes). The narrator repeatedly was stating direct pointsith points that could have been woven into the exposition more naturally, allowing me as the reader to engage my thinking and draw guided conclusions. The dialogue between characters also seemed to be an attempt at world-building or cluing the reader into the motivations of characters, and that felt unnatural and cumbersome to me.

I also really struggled with the wide fluctuations in volume in the second half of the audiobook. I was continually adjusting my speaker volume to compensate.

Despite this book not being a good fit for me, I can see some appeal that I believe many readers will enjoy. I think it may be a good fit for new adult readers who enjoy “romantasy”.

Thank you again to HarperAudio Adult for the Audio ARC.