You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
Bookshops & Bonedust
by Travis Baldree
adventurous
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
relaxing
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
tldr/summary:
This novel has a lot of similarities to the original Legends & Lattes to the point where it feels like a different version of the same story instead of its own thing. Whether that is a problem to you, I cannot say. To me, this is the better story and it was different enough that I was not bothered by the many similarities.
Long version:
This novel is very difficult to judge. The reason for that is that it feels less like a prequel and more like an improved version of the same story again. You have an orc who puts the mercenary job to the side and stays in a small town. There she meets and befriends people, errects a (failing) shop into big success and involuntarily has to deal with threats of crime and villainy. This goes even to small details like having a neighbour with a passion for baking (except this time she's actually good at it).
And whether you enjoy this story depends heavily on whether that annoys you or not. I personally found for myself that there was enough new content to make it worth my time. And the stuff that resembles content from Legends & Lattes has been improved upon - which has the weird side effect that it makes the original story retroactively worse because I now notice the missed potential of L&L more.
One of these things are the side characters. The amount of them probably hasn't been reduced that much, but most of them have been given more depth compared to for example Thimble the baker or that one bard guy. Most side characters here undergo some kind of change throughout the pages and are generally more memorable.
Also the plot as a whole has been executed more elegantly. The threat of Varine the Necromancer has been established early on and is built upon until the final climax, compared to L&L where many plot beats feel kind of episodic and are created and discarded every so often.
Now I have to point out, this is still a very cozy story, so the stakes aren't too high. While the story of Varine is handled and concluded very satisfyingly, there are some bits that feel a bit anticlimactic when they are resolved, or something is hinted at that doesn't happen.
At one point Viv receives a sword that was owned by the necromancer before. Sprinkled throughout the chapters are a few paragraphs that read like the sword is cursed and tries to corrupt Viv into caring only about said sword, rather than her friends or her old sword. However this goes nowhere and it's just a really good sword.
There are also some ways I wished B&B went specifically into a different direction than L&L. This story plays at the beginning of Viv's mercenary career, yet it is established early on that she's already rich enough that paying for a room in an inn for several weeks and buying furniture for a friend is nothing to worry about for her. Fern, the owner of the titular bookshop, says every now and then she's almost broke, yet it always seems to be just enough for what she needs to buy at the moment.
And though the romance subplot did have an interesting little twist on it - even compared to romance plots from other authors - it felt not really necessary to include.
Overall however it still stands as the superior story to Legends & Lattes, despite the weird situation of how similar the stories are to one another, or maybe precisely because of that.
This novel has a lot of similarities to the original Legends & Lattes to the point where it feels like a different version of the same story instead of its own thing. Whether that is a problem to you, I cannot say. To me, this is the better story and it was different enough that I was not bothered by the many similarities.
Long version:
This novel is very difficult to judge. The reason for that is that it feels less like a prequel and more like an improved version of the same story again. You have an orc who puts the mercenary job to the side and stays in a small town. There she meets and befriends people, errects a (failing) shop into big success and involuntarily has to deal with threats of crime and villainy. This goes even to small details like having a neighbour with a passion for baking (except this time she's actually good at it).
And whether you enjoy this story depends heavily on whether that annoys you or not. I personally found for myself that there was enough new content to make it worth my time. And the stuff that resembles content from Legends & Lattes has been improved upon - which has the weird side effect that it makes the original story retroactively worse because I now notice the missed potential of L&L more.
One of these things are the side characters. The amount of them probably hasn't been reduced that much, but most of them have been given more depth compared to for example Thimble the baker or that one bard guy. Most side characters here undergo some kind of change throughout the pages and are generally more memorable.
Also the plot as a whole has been executed more elegantly. The threat of Varine the Necromancer has been established early on and is built upon until the final climax, compared to L&L where many plot beats feel kind of episodic and are created and discarded every so often.
Now I have to point out, this is still a very cozy story, so the stakes aren't too high. While the story of Varine is handled and concluded very satisfyingly, there are some bits that feel a bit anticlimactic when they are resolved, or something is hinted at that doesn't happen.
There are also some ways I wished B&B went specifically into a different direction than L&L. This story plays at the beginning of Viv's mercenary career, yet it is established early on that she's already rich enough that paying for a room in an inn for several weeks and buying furniture for a friend is nothing to worry about for her. Fern, the owner of the titular bookshop, says every now and then she's almost broke, yet it always seems to be just enough for what she needs to buy at the moment.
And though the romance subplot did have an interesting little twist on it - even compared to romance plots from other authors - it felt not really necessary to include.
Overall however it still stands as the superior story to Legends & Lattes, despite the weird situation of how similar the stories are to one another, or maybe precisely because of that.