Take a photo of a barcode or cover
wart 's review for:
Of Introductions And Abductions
by Robert Dahlen
Things I Find While Shelving
I received a free ARC via NetGalley
The first sign that this book and I were not going to get along was right at the beginning, at the six percent mark, when one of the MCs - Beth - meets up with her professor in the quad. This quote: Puck had taken a liking to her as well, and thankfully not in that way that would have been highly unethical but gotten her an A. Enraged me. Because making light of coercive teacher/student relationships is one of those things that automatically makes me side-eye the shit out of a work.
And it never went uphill from there.
It didn’t really go down hill, either. It wasn’t atrocious. It’s well enough written, but very simplistic. It’s all surface, no real depth. Some of the dialogue and action scenes felt like they belonged in a cartoon rather than a book - which, actually, I’d watch the shit out of a cartoon of this because it’s super cool. It’s just frustrating when a book reads more like it wants to be in the visual media than the written one.
Another thing that really bothered me was that Beth always seems to know the gender of fairy and non-human characters. Even ones that look like dinosaurs or whatever. She automatically has the in on what gender they identify as. Including one where she knew because the female was apparently wearing make up. These are creatures that look DRASTICALLY different than humans and they’re sitting at home with no seemings (this book’s word for glamours) on, why the hell does she give a shit if she’s wearing human-style make up?
And why are they all male or female? Why do they all have human concepts of gender? You have this host of non human characters so you can do whatever the fuck you want with gender, and instead you…don’t.
It’s just so frustrating.
I received a free ARC via NetGalley
The first sign that this book and I were not going to get along was right at the beginning, at the six percent mark, when one of the MCs - Beth - meets up with her professor in the quad. This quote: Puck had taken a liking to her as well, and thankfully not in that way that would have been highly unethical but gotten her an A. Enraged me. Because making light of coercive teacher/student relationships is one of those things that automatically makes me side-eye the shit out of a work.
And it never went uphill from there.
It didn’t really go down hill, either. It wasn’t atrocious. It’s well enough written, but very simplistic. It’s all surface, no real depth. Some of the dialogue and action scenes felt like they belonged in a cartoon rather than a book - which, actually, I’d watch the shit out of a cartoon of this because it’s super cool. It’s just frustrating when a book reads more like it wants to be in the visual media than the written one.
Another thing that really bothered me was that Beth always seems to know the gender of fairy and non-human characters. Even ones that look like dinosaurs or whatever. She automatically has the in on what gender they identify as. Including one where she knew because the female was apparently wearing make up. These are creatures that look DRASTICALLY different than humans and they’re sitting at home with no seemings (this book’s word for glamours) on, why the hell does she give a shit if she’s wearing human-style make up?
And why are they all male or female? Why do they all have human concepts of gender? You have this host of non human characters so you can do whatever the fuck you want with gender, and instead you…don’t.
It’s just so frustrating.