This one had some proper adventure in it and perfectly sound twists. I loved how each island gave a new adventure, some big and some small. The beginning did have me fearing a bit, as I did not like the idea of a book with a whining person in it, but that resolved rather quickly and the way that it was resolved was marvelous. The ending felt unfisihed for me, I wanted the boat to return to Narnia but there wouldnt have been much adventure in that, just gay merry people, and that isnt very exciting.