aspineline's profile picture

aspineline 's review for:

4.0
challenging emotional informative slow-paced

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Choosing to listen to an audiobook like this was soooo nerdy of me, and I really enjoyed it 🧙 It’s also a way to interact with the HP world that does not ultimately benefit JKR, who has turned into the problematic villain she wrote about. The amount of thought and research that went into this book is astounding. I thought my Harry Potter knowledge is pretty extensive, but Khaytman is on another level. The book reads like an incredibly in-depth essay on Dumbledore’s timeline and motivations throughout all seven books, complete with footnotes and quotes pulled from the text. Many of the connections he made had my jaw on the floor; the way he could infer and extrapolate what was going on behind the scenes of the book was astounding. There were a few times where I felt like he was explaining things he felt JKR did on purpose when IMO she was likely explaining things/showing scenes for the readers benefit; but either way, the theories were interesting. This is dense, at times dry, got a bit repetitive at times, and clearly only suited for dedicated fans (read: dorks like me). But I got a lot out of it. ⚡️