I would say this was about a 3.5 or 3.75, but I liked the series so much i figured i would round up instead of down. This book was a little tamer than the others which i actually really like it gave balance to the series. I like Jamie's writing, I like the story. She draws you in and you want to know more about there loves. I will say this book was a little repetitive with their issues but they were likable characters. Lol