chrisssl 's review for:

One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel García Márquez
5.0
challenging dark reflective medium-paced
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

This book has a pretty fearsome reputation and from the first few pages, it's clear why.  The quality and lushness of the prose here is quite literally overwhelming.  This is a DENSE read; there's almost no dialogue; the voice is third person omniscient which routinely skips backwards and forwards by decades in telling the tale, giving rise to a scope which feels biblical despite revolving entirely around one family and this one town of Macondo.  To this reader, reading five pages of 100 Years of Solitude felt like the effort and achievement one gets from reading several chapters of your pick of acclaimed 20th century American novels.

The plot, as it were, can hardly be described as propulsive, and yet this novel is carried less by its intrigues than the sheer delight of its written word, the way it manages to paint the setting into your mind - to the point where one is shocked to find that extremely affecting and memorable moments are, upon revisiting them, in truth, only a few sentences long but echo in the mind as if they were pages-long.  I have never seen this level of prose before and lack the right way to describe why it works so well.  Marquez (and/or his English translator) love an adjective, and yet despite the writing swimming in them, none feel superfluous - each one unlocks a texture to each sentence that feels absolutely necessary.  And like other classics, Marquez plays with the rhythm; anaphora and repetitions abound - to a lesser writer it would produce something indulgent and monotonous but for Marquez it feels like the sentences are formed as an instantaneous whole thought, rather than the fatigued reciting of lists.

Several moments of gorgeous writing stand out as I write this review

  1. Jose Arcadio Buendia's early expedition to find the mail-routes, carving his way through the dense humidity and underbrush, the strange twilight alien-quality of the uncharted  land and the stumbling upon a massive beached caravel undone and transformed by an unfathomable passage of time.
  2. The descriptions of characters, particularly elderly ones such as Melquiades and the nearly indefatigable Ursula, as time works through them.  They have "music in their bones" and never has senescence been so richly described.
  3. The final day of Colonel Aureliano Buendia, the tepid early light lancing his hermitage, the humidity and its break, the rain-washed sky and fatal indulgence in nostalgia, reminding the character and the reader of happier times of wonderment in the first pages of the book.
  4. The hours/days/weeks long rant of the cruel Fernanda, who engenders no empathy before this stunning pages-long run-on sentence of her unappreciated labors, slights, frustrations and mistreatments by various other characters that lends both new perspective to this frequently maligned character, and also serves as a moment of bewildering humour.
  5. The way the novel, within the span of 50 pages can dance in the busy, rich metropolitan bustle, to antediluvian purges of rainfall, horrifying detached imagery of massacre and desiccated wastes of a dystopia.

I focus this review on the book's pure aesthetic quality because, for better or worse, it absolutely overwhelms me to the point where a careful understanding of the subtext behind this tragic family will almost certainly require one or more re-reads.  Certainly it can be understood in the final third of the novel how each of the Buendias and the unfortunate souls who find their way into this poisoned family tree, have a great diversity of character and drive, and yet frustratingly carry each a familiar hubris and dark, seemingly genetic, predisposition to self-sabotage, leading each and every one of them into their own form of solitude.  Here Marquez pulls no punches in contrasting the wonderment and near Eden-like beginnings of the town of Macondo, with the revelation of the inhabitants' brutal dark minds - which cover everything from pedophilia, incest, forced-prostitution, and bestiality.  But Marquez works his pen's magic again, because his style is at times so high-minded and detached, as if we were reading Homer's Odyssey, that these obscene transgressions almost wash over the reader to soften their horror.

Make no mistake, this book is a tragedy and one which does not offer up an easy self-unifying fatal flaw to its diverse cast of characters.  A careful re-reading is certainly in order - and yet I don't feel as if the author intends to hid some singular treatise, some capital T truth in this tale, so much as a diversity of episodes both edifying and castigating the world; a tale in which the  real tragedy and undercurrent of horror comes from the fact that the magical surrealism of the setting does not allow the novel to escape into fantasy, and instead roots it in a disturbing though somewhat strange reality.  Solitude becomes a loaded word in this story and it has layers and nuances that Marquez explores through his characters - solitude through intellectual obsession, solitude through childhood abandonment and trauma, solitude as a learned, socialized behaviour, solitude through genuine love, solitude of the stupid patriarchal ignorance that casts off all maternal wisdom and affection once obligations of child-rearing and early education are met.  It paints a stunning portrait of an idea or condition which Marquez seems to view as a terminal and, contradictorily, collective affliction.

I don't mean to oversell the grim fatalism of this book.  Like the best tragedies, this darkness must contrast with moments where the light of humanity shines bright.  One thinks of the innocent idiot, Remedios the Beauty, how her imperceptibility both spares and dooms her, of Meme's vivid passion of the world and the way she perceives and surrenders to young love, of voracious Jose Aureliano Segundo and his mistress Petra Cotes whose relationship sublimates into something beyond adultery and carnality, of my absolute favourite character of Ursula, enduring a century of hardship, holding the family, the house and the town together, unappreciated, defying old age and tragically witnessing six generations of her family and the mess they make, however much she toils to keep the world on the straight and narrow.

This is a book that took me around five months to finish - far and away the longest I've ever taken to complete a book.  Forty minutes of reading might get me only through five or six pages, such is the density of Marquez's writing.  What is more, the book does not necessarily invite quick turns-of-page or the impetus to forge ahead.  Instead the book feels like something that is ambivalent to starting and stopping - made complicated by the fact that there are so many characters in the family, sharing such similar names that any prolonged pausing in this book requires one to revisit the helpful family-tree and skimming through past chapters  to reorient oneself.  But when one does finally read the final pages of the book, I don't want to say there's an immediate feeling of reward and importance, but neither is there any sense that the time and effort spent reading has been wasted.

This is a novel that I'll need to ruminate on long after I've read, and hopefully re-read it.  There are still open questions to me about the final sentence of the book, of the ending which dabbles in meta-textuality and destiny - to what purpose?  It's not a novel I could give instinctive opinions or commentary on, instead I'll let this sit a while and see what new forms it takes over time.  But what I imagine remains immutable in this novel, is an absolutely unmatched level of writing through translation and prose which can't help but leap off the page in its vividness and beauty.