Nominated for best single issue. So far, I’ve read the winning story Batman: One Bad Day: The Riddler, which was exceptional, as well as A Vicious Circle book 1–also exceptional. This… was fine. It is interesting because it is a number of short stories with different artists, but really the main story is the Whil Wheaton one. That did feel like the best and with the most meat on the bone. But it also felt pandering to ST fans, assuming you knew stuff I did not. Plus, it’s overly sentimental. As such, this is a super fans wet dream and didn’t mean much more to me than a passable concept and a good execution of one story, with the others being shrug worthy efforts.