Take a photo of a barcode or cover
cjeanne99 's review for:
When I Was You
by Amber Garza
dark
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Solid plot line for a Lifetime movie (and I mean that as a compliment). Kelly Medina, wife of Rafael, a college professor who “stays in the Bay Area” on weekdays at some un-named home that he can pay for on his professor’s salary while Kelly lives in their house in the suburbs - somewhere south of San Francisco. That plot line aside - Kelly focused her life on her son Aaron. When Aaron went to college, she tried to find work, but still spent her time going to yoga classes with her friend Christine, and keeping her home spotless, the way Raf likes it. Aaron dies at school, and Kelly spirals into depression, even picking up a small child at the grocery store, thinking Aaron has come back to her.
Kelly sees a therapist, is getting better, and then - she gets a phone call from the pediatrician reminding her of her upcoming well baby check for her son. Turns out there is a new Kelly Medina in town - and narrator Kelly Medina concocts a way to meet her. Soon, Kelly Medina #1 is inserting herself into the life of single mom Kelly Medina with baby Sullivan. Side story about Kelly #1 having an imaginary friend as a child, makes the reader wonder if she is making up the other Kelly when BFF Christine spots her at a restaurant, claiming she is having lunch with Kelly #2, even though K2’s plate has been “cleared away” and K2 is in the bathroom with baby Sullivan.
But oh yes, K2 is real. With Rafael spending weekends in the city (he’s got papers to grade, his dad fell and needs help), K1 has time to obsess about K2 and baby Sullivan. Her behavior turns to stalking, making you question her sanity. But when K2 shows up at Kelly and Rafael’s house, everything changes.Turns out - Rafael is the father of Sullivan, not Aaron as Kelly had suspected. K1 realizes that K2 is KEITH on Rafael’s phone - tries to attack K2 - but instead K2 hits Kelly on the head - and - thinking she is dead, drags her to the shed in the backyard. K2 thinks she is building a new life with baby Sullivan and Rafael - not understanding that Rafael wanted the fun, not the family. K1 escapes from the shed, and sneaks into the house to listen to Raf and K2 talking. She uses Aaron’s cell phone to call 911, protects baby Sullivan, and records K2 telling Raf that she caused Aaron’s OD by drugging his drink. K2 has a gun on Raf - I guess because he’s telling her that he doesn’t want to move away with her and is asking where K1 is - gun struggle - Rafael is hit. He comes home from the hospital - and Kelly follows the doctor’s orders to watch him carefully, his condition is unstable. She smothers him.
In the end, Kelly prevails.
Kelly sees a therapist, is getting better, and then - she gets a phone call from the pediatrician reminding her of her upcoming well baby check for her son. Turns out there is a new Kelly Medina in town - and narrator Kelly Medina concocts a way to meet her. Soon, Kelly Medina #1 is inserting herself into the life of single mom Kelly Medina with baby Sullivan. Side story about Kelly #1 having an imaginary friend as a child, makes the reader wonder if she is making up the other Kelly when BFF Christine spots her at a restaurant, claiming she is having lunch with Kelly #2, even though K2’s plate has been “cleared away” and K2 is in the bathroom with baby Sullivan.
But oh yes, K2 is real. With Rafael spending weekends in the city (he’s got papers to grade, his dad fell and needs help), K1 has time to obsess about K2 and baby Sullivan. Her behavior turns to stalking, making you question her sanity. But when K2 shows up at Kelly and Rafael’s house, everything changes.
In the end, Kelly prevails.