wart's profile picture

wart 's review for:

All Kinds of Other by James Sie
4.0
emotional

 I received a free ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review

This book had some rough moments, so just gonna throw up some general warnings for: Transphobia, misgendering, forced outing, bullying

Spoilers below!

Jules is starting at another new school after a shitty experience at his old one. His mom isn't too happy with this school, so she assures him she'll find a better one, but Jules is kind of sick of constantly moving around and besides, as long as he gets to play basketball, he's happy. Sure, he's just come out as gay and sure that brings its own challenges, but Jules has friends at this school and he's pretty sure he'll be okay.

Jack is in LA with his dad, each doing their own Great Experiment. His dad's? Try to get his acting career started. Jack's? Go stealth. Far away from anyone who knew him before he came out, away from people who watched his transition. He just wants to be a regular teenage boy, no labels, no stares.

Jules and Jack click. They slowly start to get to know each other, start flirting, start maybe navigating towards something despite Jack wanting to pull back. Jack knows if they do start dating, start anything, he'll have to tell Jules and he's scared of how that will change things between them. So he keeps putting it off.

But a link to an old youtube video Jack made before he began medical transition gets sent around the school, taking the decision out of Jack's hands. And the fallout after is a lot to navigate, for both of them.

Sie does an excellent job with this story. The emotions, Jack's fear and dysphoria and Jules's tendency to get stuck. It's all so well crafted and well told. I found myself really invested in the characters, frustrated by the things that were frustrating. All Kinds of Other is so well written and well done. I thought Jack's experiences were handled particularly well.