I would give this a solid 3 because it was a cozy read for sure. The premise and the context was good. The story build up was also great. However, it got a bit blurry towards the end. One of the plot twist was good. The reveal was bad was not memorable.  I was not able to guess the killer my guess was all wrong. Usually I would have loved it if I couldn’t guess but the reveal felt a bit lacking in terms of character build up for the killer. However the next plot twist was good.