awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

Red at the Bone by Jacqueline Woodson
2.0

This book was stunningly written and beautiful to read. I had a few major issues with it that frankly, ruined the book for me.

The timing was wacky. The first chapter is present day, and the rest of the book jumps around from way back when to every other time period in between. Alone, that wouldn't be a big deal. But with that, Woodson also jumps around between characters with no clear distinction as to who is who. There's 5 characters you could be reading about, and it takes a couple pages at least to figure out which one and what time period you are currently reading in. As I said, alone these problems wouldn't be huge but together it makes for a confusing book.

I also had to re-read the ending to figure out what was actually going on. And why. And who. I don't mind books that make me think and do a little work, but the entire time felt like this book had a couple more rounds of drafts to go through before meeting it's true potential.