A review by ambershelf
You Were Always Mine by Christine Pride, Jo Piazza

4.0

Cinnamon Haynes has achieved the impossible after a tough childhood—she has a husband, a stable job, and a cozy house. But when she finds an abandoned white baby with a note from her unlikely friend Daisy, asking her to raise the child, Cinnamon is faced with past ghosts and present problems, threatening to upend her seemingly perfect life.

MINE delves into the complex realm of motherhood, showcasing women's diverse perspectives and relationships with this role. This book also sheds light on foster care & adoption, and the pervasive influence of racism within the system that continues to uphold white supremacy.

My favorite part about MINE is the central theme that motherhood is a peculiar journey where everyone seems to have an opinion—even those who aren't/can't become mothers—vehemently believing that their view is the only correct one. I also adore Pride & Piazza's exploration of entrenched racism within the childcare system, drawing attention to the unfortunate tendency of placing BIPOC children with white parents while the reverse scenario is far less prevalent.

I want to mention that Cinnamon & Daisy had to make some pretty incredulous decisions for the plot to continue, requiring a suspension of disbelief, as several circumstances must align perfectly for such a situation to occur. And while the plot development verges on the happier side, the ending feels a bit rushed and the pacing off. The resolution arrives swiftly, tying up loose ends and bringing closer to the storyline.

I can see MINE being an excellent selection for book clubs in a professional setting, as it raises important questions about motherhood & racism. However, for those seeking a more profound examination of race & adoption, I recommend THE HOUSE OF EVE (Sedeqa Johnson), SOMEWHERE SISTERS (Erika Hayasaki), DUST CHILD (Nguyễn Phan Quế Mai), and MIKA IN REAL LIFE (Emiko Jean). I'd love some recs centering on Black children being adopted by white families too!

Thank you to Scribner Books & Book Club favorites for the gifted ARC