candelibri's profile picture

candelibri 's review for:

Sky Full of Elephants by Cebo Campbell
2.5
challenging emotional tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I don’t know how concise my thoughts will be so I’m going to try to divide them into characters/ themes:

1. The Black-white binary
I appreciate the exclusion of white people as a theme, in fact, that was a main reason I picked this up! Yet, the exclusion of all other non-Black POC was jarring to a point of discomfort. They were mentioned all of three times in this book, primarily in passing and at one point out of surprise (ex: in one passage the author noted a sight that "hadn't been seen since the early days after the Event...an Asian person"...what?!) ..why bother even mentioning this if your focus is Blackness in opposition to the absence of whiteness which very clearly seems to be the crux of the book? It just makes the absence even more awkward/mystifying. I understand wanting to examine Blackness on its own, away from white supremacy but I truly can’t help feeling that it is impossible (if not disingenuous) to try to do that *in the US* with the complete absence of the Native Americans at the very least! 

2. Sydney
Oh Syd…I understand why you needed a character so very different for the story but I have such a hard time believing her! Why would a family who was - literally - so racist to her father and so adamant at holding that racial line, treat her as if she were fully white? That family dynamic was the hardest to understand and I think caused the most tension (not the good kind) as every time Sydney acted on an impulse, I was questioning her or rolling my eyes. And then when she suddenly turned on her aunt, I didn’t believe her. 

3. The idea of frequency
This part I loved - I wish more time had been spent on this. Where the whole point was trying to bring a fractured, marginalized people together. The first attempt though, was what caused the first exodus of all the white people. The second brought the group it was meant for together. 

4. The US vs the Kingdom
So, this is where I understand the dichotomy is needed for the story but I think the author does a disservice to Black people. The US one year post-Event is portrayed as chaotic, wild; people are shell-shocked and the atmosphere is general mayhem. When Sydney and her father go to O’Hare to get a flight to Alabama (“the Kingdom”), they’re told “no one will fly there” bc of horror stories of disappearing planes and people who do. 
Shocker, they go and find a much more utopic setting. 
I guess my skepticism comes from the fact that so many people would immediately crumble in the absence of white supremacy. I know it is a device for the story, yet everything I know about Black people in my own life tells me they would be JUST FINE. 

All in all, this is a great premise for a book that asks some great questions, I just don’t know if the execution was achieved. I will also acknowledge that this book may not be for me!