Yeah, this is a solid 3.5. Changed my original rating because I made it long after I had read this book. Its good. And at the time, a unique type of urban fantasy. I listened to the audiobook this time and its not as amazing as I was expecting from other reviews. But its good. Overall this is definitely an opener. If the Dresden Files had stayed at this level I wouldn't be as big of a fan. I love the magic. Harry is relatable in so many ways. He is the Peter Parker of the wizarding world, or even the urban fantasy world.