I am so happy to return to Oakwood Bay! If you love fake dating, sports romance, and off the charts chemistry, Only Between Us delivers all of that and more and I think it was so much better than the first book. This sequel to Only in Your Dreams is packed with tension, banter, and just the right amount of drama to keep you hooked.

Brooks Attwood is trying to make a football comeback after a brutal injury, but his plans take a hit when some very unfortunate photos surface. Enter Siena Pippen, who is the ex girlfriend of the NFL’s golden boy and someone who really doesn’t want to be dragged back into that world. When a viral selfie makes it look like they’re dating, Brooks and Siena realize they can use the attention to their advantage. Their solution? A good old fashioned fake relationship. Easy, right? (Spoiler: not at all.)

I loved the push and pull dynamic between Brooks and Siena. Their chemistry is undeniable, but what really sold me was how much they challenged each other. Brooks is determined to win back his spot in the league, while Siena is fiercely independent and guarded after her past relationship. Watching them go from reluctant allies to something very real was so satisfying. Plus, the slow burn? Absolutely perfect.

Beyond the romance, there’s a lot to love about this book—family struggles, career pressures, and the realities of being in the public eye all add depth to the story. But at its heart, it’s an emotional, steamy, and wildly entertaining ride that will have you rooting for Brooks and Siena every step of the way.

If you’re a fan of sports romance with lots of tension and banter, Only Between Us perfect. Ellie K. Wilde nails the fake dating trope in a way that feels fresh, fun, and full of heart.

Thank you to NetGalley, Ellie K. Wilde, and Atria Books for the eARC of this book.