Take a photo of a barcode or cover
cjeanne99 's review for:
Broken Harbor
by Tana French
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Mike Kennedy is assigned to look into the murder of Pat Spain and his two children - and the attempted murder of mom Jennifer Spain. The Spains live in Brianstown - aka - Broken Harbor - a seaside development north of the city - that has many unfinished homes due to the housing bust.
Kennedy has some family history with Broken Harbor - which has nothing to do with the story - other than to explain why his sister Dina is crazy.
Back to the Spains. They bought the house early on - started their family. Everything was picture perfect. Pat had a great job, Jennifer drives an SUV, is the loving mother, taking Emma to school and Jack to preschool. Then Pat loses his job - and - with an apparent mink infestation in their house - he loses his mind.
As Kennedy and his new to the Murder Squad partner Richie, investigate - they find multiple oddities. Starting with - holes in the walls, seven baby monitors, chicken wire in the ceiling and a voyeur’s nest in a neighboring building complete with binoculars to look in on the Spain’s kitchen.
The investigation focuses on Conor Brennan, the man who set up the nest - and - turns out to be a growing up best friend of the Spains and Emma’s godfather. What happened to cause their estrangement? Looking like Conor is the murderer - complete with a confession. But Richie keeps insisting that they should look at Pat Spain. His online searches to find a solution for the infestation in the attic lead the detectives down a path that makes Kennedy believe that Pat went crazy, Jennifer reached out to Conor for assistance - and Conor acted to “rescue” Jennifer by murdering Pat. But why the children as well? It doesn’t add up.
Kennedy is focused on Brennan, Richie is focused on Spain - and it all blows up when Dina follows Richie home to ask where Kennedy is. Richie has no idea that Dina is Mike’s sister - he thinks she is a friend. She finds an evidence bag at Richie’s house - tries to take it to Mike at the station - but is intercepted by Mike’s nemesis Quigley. When Mike finally gets his hands on the evidence bag - he confronts Richie with hiding a crucial piece of evidence - which Richie defends in a lackluster manner. In a way - Mike’s crazy sister blows the case open.
Note for myself - what Richie found was a woman’s pink fingernail at Conor’s apartment - implicating Jennifer. Kennedy goes to the hospital and gets an un documented confession from Jennifer that she couldn’t take Pat’s obsession with the mink - the harm it was doing to the children - how it was breaking up their perfectly happy family. She put the children to bed - and then sometime towards dawn, smothered her two children, went downstairs and attacked her husband with a kitchen knife, and attempted to kill herself with the same knife. She might have succeeded - except that Conor was in his nest. Seeing the struggle with Pat - he came over to the house - but Pat was dead. Jennifer kept telling him that she did it to rescue the children - begged Conor to let her join them. He wiped the internet history from Pat’s laptop - and took the knife away with him. Leaving one muddy footprint.
In the end - we get the story of what happened to Mike and Dina’s mother out on Broken Harbor - which caused Dina’s mind to break. Well done.
Kennedy has some family history with Broken Harbor - which has nothing to do with the story - other than to explain why his sister Dina is crazy.
Back to the Spains. They bought the house early on - started their family. Everything was picture perfect. Pat had a great job, Jennifer drives an SUV, is the loving mother, taking Emma to school and Jack to preschool. Then Pat loses his job - and - with an apparent mink infestation in their house - he loses his mind.
As Kennedy and his new to the Murder Squad partner Richie, investigate - they find multiple oddities. Starting with - holes in the walls, seven baby monitors, chicken wire in the ceiling and a voyeur’s nest in a neighboring building complete with binoculars to look in on the Spain’s kitchen.
The investigation focuses on Conor Brennan, the man who set up the nest - and - turns out to be a growing up best friend of the Spains and Emma’s godfather. What happened to cause their estrangement? Looking like Conor is the murderer - complete with a confession. But Richie keeps insisting that they should look at Pat Spain. His online searches to find a solution for the infestation in the attic lead the detectives down a path that makes Kennedy believe that Pat went crazy, Jennifer reached out to Conor for assistance - and Conor acted to “rescue” Jennifer by murdering Pat. But why the children as well? It doesn’t add up.
Kennedy is focused on Brennan, Richie is focused on Spain - and it all blows up when Dina follows Richie home to ask where Kennedy is. Richie has no idea that Dina is Mike’s sister - he thinks she is a friend. She finds an evidence bag at Richie’s house - tries to take it to Mike at the station - but is intercepted by Mike’s nemesis Quigley. When Mike finally gets his hands on the evidence bag - he confronts Richie with hiding a crucial piece of evidence - which Richie defends in a lackluster manner. In a way - Mike’s crazy sister blows the case open.
In the end - we get the story of what happened to Mike and Dina’s mother out on Broken Harbor - which caused Dina’s mind to break. Well done.