Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Priory of the Orange Tree
by Samantha Shannon
adventurous
challenging
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr/summary
The novel has a lot of things going for it, but also a lot to criticize. It is good in essence, but a lot of parts were inelegantly executed. There was a lot that could and should have been shortened or streamlined and the pacing needed reconstruction to make the story more consistently entertaining. If you manage to get through the first half of the experience, things start to actually become interesting and investing, but it’s hard to say if that’s worth going through the boring part. It is overall a pleasant novel however.
The worldbuilding is phenomenal. The characters can be hit or miss, but are generally satisfying. The plot is interesting and good, but has a lot of boring or annoying bits in it as well.
Long version:
The Worldbuilding
The worldbuilding is the highlight of the novel. It is particularly fascinating to see the history and mythology of every place and culture blur into one another and to untangle which is which. Every place feels very believable in the way their history influenced their believes, their believes influenced their culture and their culture influenced their history.
A central part of the world is the different religions and how they interplay with one another. What is interesting here is that all religions are based on the same event in history, they all agree that a thousand years ago, a dragon crawled from the earth and almost destroyed it, were it not for the people who fought and defeated him back then. But every belief has a different opinion on what exactly happened, which conclusions to draw from those events and what the future holds for the world. This is very effectively used to demonstrate how every culture differs from the others, how and why they developed differently.
This is also shown in their way of historical record keeping. Aside from the appearance of the Nameless One – said evil dragon – there are countless other events in the past that shaped the world. Which people choose to remember which events is used to great effect. While one part of the world may have kept extensive records on a certain event, another considers that knowledge as heretic and rejects remembering it. There is also a fair share of knowledge that over time people started to assume was mere untrue myth, therefore the precise knowledge of these events faded into obscurity in favor of a story; or they are not kept in cultural and academic memory at all. And then there are the things that past rulers and people purposefully tried to destroy and forget for one reason or another.
History, religion and myth blur into each other realistically and believably in this world. It becomes a fascinating act to untangle them and learn the – actually really interesting – truth of the world, its past and future.
A central theme of the novel is the idea of overcoming prejudices and working together despite our differences. A lot of the world is built on certain dualities which can be felt strongly in many aspects, from politics to history, religion and the mindset of every individual person. Usually there’s two parts of one concept (e.g. fire dragons and water dragons, earth magic and star magic, East and West) but there are far more than only two views on these things. For example, while some people are hostile towards magic, others actively embrace it and use it for good (or evil). Others again might not even be aware that magic is real or that it is separated into two branches.
The novel shows how every individual person is shaped by generations of societies forming opinions on the world, other peoples, religions and more. Even protagonists and genuinely good people need to learn to overcome such societal norms. They see others as allies or enemies purely on their cultural heritage, whether that is true or not. It is not uncommon that this mentality leads characters to the wrong conclusions. They ignore vital evidence if it is given to them by the wrong source or overlook warning signs that a trusted ally may not actually have their interests in mind and lies to them.
But it also shows how these believes affect global politics. We see how they led to the loss of important knowledge for various unjustifiable, prejudiced or self-serving reasons. We see how governments are reluctant to ally with other nations if their religion doesn’t match, even though all of them want to overcome the same threat and there are only benefits to collaboration. Sometimes, rulers act purely on the mentality of ‘They hate us so we don’t even have to try forming an intercultural alliance.’.
However this part suffers a lot from the novel’s pacing. While it is very interesting to explore how the individual nations fight their mutual reluctance to form a multinational and multi-religious alliance, it is cut short by how late in the story this subplot actually begins. At that point there are so few pages left that the individual governments literally do not have the time anymore to let their prejudices affect their judgment. They are forced to form an alliance without major difficulties because the apocalypse happens within less than a week. So this carefully set-up mantra of prejudice and fighting it falls rather flat at the end, where it might have been the most hindering to the characters and the greater good.
The characters
With over 800 pages this novel has a lot of characters, who can be very hit or miss. Generally the side characters are pleasant and enjoyable. They fulfill their purposes in the story well but rarely do much more. How fleshed out they are depends heavily on where they live. Most attention is given to the residents of Inys, who consequently make the most enjoyable cast. You really get to learn the social hierarchies, the reputations and secrets of most people at court and have a pretty good picture of the place by the end. But even here, many particularly likable side characters get ignored during the final act.
In every other place, most characters can feel lacking however. Especially the members of the Priory feel like they needed more attention and their character explorations are still rather unfinished by the end. Even the more prominent characters here feel like we barely got to know them.
But most people of the East also draw the short end of the stick. Even the PoV characters here feel like they only exist to establish their history and culture before Loth brings over the plot from Inys in the final act. After we got a feeling for the place, it is mostly disregarded for a long while. Niclays’ and Tané’s stories are too short to be evenly spread across the entire novel, so in the middle section their chapters get incredibly rare and incredibly short. Similarly, most Eastern side characters like Elder Vara, the Moyaka Family and Turosa exist only as long as they are needed and are disregarded for the rest of the story as soon as they did what they had to do.
Another weird aspect that affects characters from all over the world is Shannon’s obsession with killing side-characters, especially off-screen. At least a dozen characters die but, at best, only half of them are given the honor of a death scene (even less get ones that don’t feel way too short and rushed). Much more frequently we are given one or two sentences where a PoV character comes to a place and sees the corpse of a certain character. And then we move on as if nothing happened, as if that shouldn’t even matter to us. Shannon effectively says “Oh no, anyway…” regularly. This isn’t even fridging because usually not even the characters care much for the people who died. And most of these deaths also don’t further the plot in any way.
An example: Truyde and her lover Sulyard try to motivate the kingdoms of the East and West to stop their hostile behavior towards each other and work together against the Nameless One, who they suspect will rise again soon. Imagine now they lived to see that they were right and got their wish fulfilled. Imagine Truyde traveled with Loth to the East, meets her lover again and they progress through the plot as a duo. But no, they get killed off-page with no interesting consequences. Igrain Crest didn’t even have any particular reason to execute Truyde this quickly after seizing power; it just had to happen during that time frame because no one else would kill her.
Aside from the PoV characters, there are two characters that deserve a more elaborate examination. Queen Sabran the Ninth and Kalyba, the Witch of Inysca.
Sabran is a fascinating and tragic person. As the current ruler of a thousand-year-old royal bloodline, said to prevent the Nameless One from rising again, she has a lot of responsibilities too carry. She portrays how isolating being a ruler can become in a truly believable and touching manner. Even before we learn of the several conspiracies intended to take her power from her, we sense the doom she is threatened with, the scars she has been and will be inflicted.
Though she is the most powerful queen of the continent, she is imprisoned by her religious and political duties. An important example of this is how she is scared to conceive a child, for various reasons, but obligated to do so for the good of her country. Several conflicts arise from this, like the fact that she refuses to marry a man because this would soon result in her pregnancy. However by doing so, she only enhances her crushing isolation on her own, driving away people who love her and angering other members of the government. This system hurts her deeply but when she tries to rebel against it, she is also hurt by it.
Kalyba on the other hand is ruler of nothing but has full control of her own life and everyone around her. She is an immortal being who has been there when the Nameless One first rose and fell a thousand years ago and the Kingdom of Inys was founded. This gives her a lot of information that the mortals desperately crave or need. But while she doesn’t lie, she is reluctant to reveal all the details if she isn’t explicitly asked or forced to do so. When she speaks however, it really doesn’t feel as if she leaves out important details. Even if one suspects that she is not telling the (full) truth, the stories she tells seem complete and true until one learns what she left out.
Shannon also puts on full display how an immortal being would have a different set of morals from mortals, completely incomprehensible to them but internally consistent. Those believes are also partly influenced by the values popular by the time she first gained immortality. Because of that it is actually believable when she claims not to have any evil intentions. Still there’s enough room for doubt – due to her actions, words and more – that even to the very end, the reader can’t quite be sure whether Kalyba should be considered evil or just antagonistic.
The PoV characters are complicated to describe. Like the plot, they need a lot of time before they start to shine – that is if they shine at all. For the first half of the novel, all of them are incredibly passive and have no interest in actually furthering a plot or upsetting the status quo. This can be especially exhausting when you don’t yet have an idea where they and the plot are supposed to go.
Ead
Ead is tasked with watching over Sabran so that she doesn’t die. Therefore she mostly idles around in the palace until later on she is forced to leave and actually become active and truly investing. In the beginning, she didn’t even choose or enjoy that mission, but when she is offered to change her life situation by her ‘employer’, she effectively says: “I’d rather stay here and make sure no plot happens.”
Tané
At the start of the novel, Tané involuntarily witnesses the arrival of an illegal traveler. At this point she is still in military school and needs to make sure no one learns of her involvement with him. Her goal is literally: Don’t do anything that draws any attention to you. This becomes her main motivator for a major part of the first half. Even after she is found out, it takes her a while before she stops sulking and starts doing… anything really. Shannon herself seems to not know what to do with her at points, because she gets ignored for 70 pages and then shortly after for 100 pages.
Niclays
Niclays Roos is the worst offender of this crime. His motivation is literally to be left in peace and not be involved in any politics or plot and this doesn’t change until the end of the novel. Everywhere he goes, he has to be dragged to with a dagger held to his throat; everything he does, he does because others force him to.
Loth
Loth is the only one who has plot driving motivations in the beginning. Shame they’re always put onto him by someone else. First he gets exiled to a foreign kingdom to work as a spy and find out what's going on with the government there. Then the princess of that kingdom tasks him with delivering an important object to yet another kingdom. When he arrives at that kingdom, the plot ignores him for 130 pages until Ead comes into his vicinity and gets him back to his homeland, where he finally gets to make his own decisions.
This change from being passive to active happens for most characters pretty consistently between page 400 and 500, upon which the plot too becomes more heated. That still doesn’t mean however that all PoV characters suddenly become enjoyable or get an interesting plot to follow.
Niclays is entirely useless to the plot and could have been cut completely, were it not for the few chapters he traveled with the Golden Empress. He is mostly useless in those too, but he provided a PoV for that section of the story. In fact, chapter 69 actively plays with the fact that he has missed effectively every major plot beat, was a useless disappointment to everyone who had ever allied with him in some way (romantic, political or otherwise) and how he had let everyone down. His absolute lack of any internal motivation to do anything led him down a path where he has really not achieved anything of relevance throughout the entire novel.
Tané on the other hand gets very strong internal motivations and is very active in the latter half. Her problem is rather that she is absolutely insufferable, both before and after the 500 page mark. Her goals are all the way through absolutely self-centered and egotistic. Every life decision she makes is purely based on how it will change her standing in the world and society. Yet she never get punished for that sentiment and always comes out on top.
This starts in chapter one, where she breaks the rules because of a superstition that is said to give her a better chance of achieving a position as dragonrider, even though it is not related to any work or necessary skill. While she is doing that, she meets an illegal traveler. Instead of dealing with him herself and revealing that she broke the rules, she loads this responsibility off to a friend. If you want to be generous, you could argue that this is the one time she ever gets punished for her actions, because her friend – not she herself – is later executed and she expelled from the dragonriders. Her dragon however remains loyal to her.
Even when it comes to doing the noble or morally right thing to do like saving a sacred dragon from imprisonment or defeating a world-ending threat, she is motivated almost exclusively by the idea of redeeming herself for past sins and becoming a dragonrider again. This results in her harming other people while she tries to right her past wrongs. She steals a ship which means its crew is completely absent from the final fight against the Nameless One, where they could have helped a great deal. Instead they are trapped on an island that does not have the resources to sustain both the ship’s crew and the locals (Tané knows that). Tané has committed so many moral sins throughout the novel but not learned a single lesson to make her a better person, even though the story wants you to believe she is actually good.
Loth and Ead are much more enjoyable, which is good considering that Loth, Tané and Niclays are more side characters in Ead’s story, rather than equal protagonists. It is probably no overstatement to say that 75%-80% of the pages are dedicated to Ead’s PoV.
The Plot
The plot of the novel is generally quite good. There is a lot happening within the span of so many pages, which has several side effects, positive and negative. For one, Shannon shows really compelling changes over time with both the people and the world. It is hard to believe that the characters we got to know in the beginning are the same ones that end the story, yet when you look at the bigger picture, their developments are perfectly logical and gradual with no big leaps. Also, with so much information given at any point in time, it is very easy to hide foreshadowing or leave out game-changing information without the reader noticing. Shannon uses this with great skill and success.
An avoidable problem however, that Shannon was not able to navigate around, is that the story takes a while to truly begin. It is only after around 400 pages that the story truly starts to gain steam and become investing – a point at which many novels have already told a complete story.
Along with this comes a rather odd pacing with strangely placed high and low points in tension. It often feels like there is a lot of slow (honestly at times boring) build-up for a climactic part of the story, that then is over way sooner than it should be. One notable example of this are how Ead returns home to the South and slowly realizes that the place has changed in a way she dislikes. Simultaneously she learns of a prisoner there she wants to break out and return to the North, where a coup is happening and needs to be stopped. That section is a slog of being fed information that will eventually be relevant. The actual retaking of the Inys government however is dealt with within two chapters, though it could have easily been at least 100 pages or more.
Another noteworthy point within the plot is the final fight against the Nameless One, the world destroying evil dragon king. It doesn’t necessarily feel too short, though it is evident that Shannon did not want to linger on this action scene (or most action scenes really) for longer than needed. The spectacle of it is very engaging and the chaos of the situation is vividly described in a way that makes your adrenaline rise. You can see the light and dust, hear the screams and sense the pain and exhaustion. It is short but does in a lot of ways live up to the hype the story wants to establish.
Still, it could have been improved in certain ways. One big problem is the fact that the Priory of the Orange Tree – the people the novel was named after – does not appear once throughout the fight, even though they have prepared themselves for it for a thousand years. There are other people, e.g. Gian Harlowe, who should be there but aren’t. Tané does get some grand scenes in which her friend and dragon dramatically appear in climactic moments. Clearly Shannon knew the impact of such scenes, so why could these other people not come?
The length of the final fight may work, but the epilogue is definitely too short. Each of the four PoV characters get their own one and they are all quite nice. They have a great sense of ‘the adventure continues’, which is definitely how these characters would lead their further lives after their recent experiences. Only Niclays gets an epilogue where he finally gets to settle down and live the last years of his life in peace at home. Again, very much in character. But too many side characters are forgotten about or only hastily mentioned in a small sentence, even though several of them would be very interesting to hear about. It is not enough to just say the Donmata Marosa is alive and well. How do Roslain and Laya hold up now?
Generally, one can say: The plot is good, but the beginning is too long and the end is too short.
The novel has a lot of things going for it, but also a lot to criticize. It is good in essence, but a lot of parts were inelegantly executed. There was a lot that could and should have been shortened or streamlined and the pacing needed reconstruction to make the story more consistently entertaining. If you manage to get through the first half of the experience, things start to actually become interesting and investing, but it’s hard to say if that’s worth going through the boring part. It is overall a pleasant novel however.
The worldbuilding is phenomenal. The characters can be hit or miss, but are generally satisfying. The plot is interesting and good, but has a lot of boring or annoying bits in it as well.
Long version:
The worldbuilding is the highlight of the novel. It is particularly fascinating to see the history and mythology of every place and culture blur into one another and to untangle which is which. Every place feels very believable in the way their history influenced their believes, their believes influenced their culture and their culture influenced their history.
A central part of the world is the different religions and how they interplay with one another. What is interesting here is that all religions are based on the same event in history, they all agree that a thousand years ago, a dragon crawled from the earth and almost destroyed it, were it not for the people who fought and defeated him back then. But every belief has a different opinion on what exactly happened, which conclusions to draw from those events and what the future holds for the world. This is very effectively used to demonstrate how every culture differs from the others, how and why they developed differently.
This is also shown in their way of historical record keeping. Aside from the appearance of the Nameless One – said evil dragon – there are countless other events in the past that shaped the world. Which people choose to remember which events is used to great effect. While one part of the world may have kept extensive records on a certain event, another considers that knowledge as heretic and rejects remembering it. There is also a fair share of knowledge that over time people started to assume was mere untrue myth, therefore the precise knowledge of these events faded into obscurity in favor of a story; or they are not kept in cultural and academic memory at all. And then there are the things that past rulers and people purposefully tried to destroy and forget for one reason or another.
History, religion and myth blur into each other realistically and believably in this world. It becomes a fascinating act to untangle them and learn the – actually really interesting – truth of the world, its past and future.
A central theme of the novel is the idea of overcoming prejudices and working together despite our differences. A lot of the world is built on certain dualities which can be felt strongly in many aspects, from politics to history, religion and the mindset of every individual person. Usually there’s two parts of one concept (e.g. fire dragons and water dragons, earth magic and star magic, East and West) but there are far more than only two views on these things. For example, while some people are hostile towards magic, others actively embrace it and use it for good (or evil). Others again might not even be aware that magic is real or that it is separated into two branches.
The novel shows how every individual person is shaped by generations of societies forming opinions on the world, other peoples, religions and more. Even protagonists and genuinely good people need to learn to overcome such societal norms. They see others as allies or enemies purely on their cultural heritage, whether that is true or not. It is not uncommon that this mentality leads characters to the wrong conclusions. They ignore vital evidence if it is given to them by the wrong source or overlook warning signs that a trusted ally may not actually have their interests in mind and lies to them.
But it also shows how these believes affect global politics. We see how they led to the loss of important knowledge for various unjustifiable, prejudiced or self-serving reasons. We see how governments are reluctant to ally with other nations if their religion doesn’t match, even though all of them want to overcome the same threat and there are only benefits to collaboration. Sometimes, rulers act purely on the mentality of ‘They hate us so we don’t even have to try forming an intercultural alliance.’.
However this part suffers a lot from the novel’s pacing. While it is very interesting to explore how the individual nations fight their mutual reluctance to form a multinational and multi-religious alliance, it is cut short by how late in the story this subplot actually begins. At that point there are so few pages left that the individual governments literally do not have the time anymore to let their prejudices affect their judgment. They are forced to form an alliance without major difficulties because the apocalypse happens within less than a week. So this carefully set-up mantra of prejudice and fighting it falls rather flat at the end, where it might have been the most hindering to the characters and the greater good.
The characters
With over 800 pages this novel has a lot of characters, who can be very hit or miss. Generally the side characters are pleasant and enjoyable. They fulfill their purposes in the story well but rarely do much more. How fleshed out they are depends heavily on where they live. Most attention is given to the residents of Inys, who consequently make the most enjoyable cast. You really get to learn the social hierarchies, the reputations and secrets of most people at court and have a pretty good picture of the place by the end. But even here, many particularly likable side characters get ignored during the final act.
In every other place, most characters can feel lacking however. Especially the members of the Priory feel like they needed more attention and their character explorations are still rather unfinished by the end. Even the more prominent characters here feel like we barely got to know them.
But most people of the East also draw the short end of the stick. Even the PoV characters here feel like they only exist to establish their history and culture before Loth brings over the plot from Inys in the final act. After we got a feeling for the place, it is mostly disregarded for a long while. Niclays’ and Tané’s stories are too short to be evenly spread across the entire novel, so in the middle section their chapters get incredibly rare and incredibly short. Similarly, most Eastern side characters like Elder Vara, the Moyaka Family and Turosa exist only as long as they are needed and are disregarded for the rest of the story as soon as they did what they had to do.
Another weird aspect that affects characters from all over the world is Shannon’s obsession with killing side-characters, especially off-screen. At least a dozen characters die but, at best, only half of them are given the honor of a death scene (even less get ones that don’t feel way too short and rushed). Much more frequently we are given one or two sentences where a PoV character comes to a place and sees the corpse of a certain character. And then we move on as if nothing happened, as if that shouldn’t even matter to us. Shannon effectively says “Oh no, anyway…” regularly. This isn’t even fridging because usually not even the characters care much for the people who died. And most of these deaths also don’t further the plot in any way.
An example: Truyde and her lover Sulyard try to motivate the kingdoms of the East and West to stop their hostile behavior towards each other and work together against the Nameless One, who they suspect will rise again soon. Imagine now they lived to see that they were right and got their wish fulfilled. Imagine Truyde traveled with Loth to the East, meets her lover again and they progress through the plot as a duo. But no, they get killed off-page with no interesting consequences. Igrain Crest didn’t even have any particular reason to execute Truyde this quickly after seizing power; it just had to happen during that time frame because no one else would kill her.
Aside from the PoV characters, there are two characters that deserve a more elaborate examination. Queen Sabran the Ninth and Kalyba, the Witch of Inysca.
Sabran is a fascinating and tragic person. As the current ruler of a thousand-year-old royal bloodline, said to prevent the Nameless One from rising again, she has a lot of responsibilities too carry. She portrays how isolating being a ruler can become in a truly believable and touching manner. Even before we learn of the several conspiracies intended to take her power from her, we sense the doom she is threatened with, the scars she has been and will be inflicted.
Though she is the most powerful queen of the continent, she is imprisoned by her religious and political duties. An important example of this is how she is scared to conceive a child, for various reasons, but obligated to do so for the good of her country. Several conflicts arise from this, like the fact that she refuses to marry a man because this would soon result in her pregnancy. However by doing so, she only enhances her crushing isolation on her own, driving away people who love her and angering other members of the government. This system hurts her deeply but when she tries to rebel against it, she is also hurt by it.
Kalyba on the other hand is ruler of nothing but has full control of her own life and everyone around her. She is an immortal being who has been there when the Nameless One first rose and fell a thousand years ago and the Kingdom of Inys was founded. This gives her a lot of information that the mortals desperately crave or need. But while she doesn’t lie, she is reluctant to reveal all the details if she isn’t explicitly asked or forced to do so. When she speaks however, it really doesn’t feel as if she leaves out important details. Even if one suspects that she is not telling the (full) truth, the stories she tells seem complete and true until one learns what she left out.
Shannon also puts on full display how an immortal being would have a different set of morals from mortals, completely incomprehensible to them but internally consistent. Those believes are also partly influenced by the values popular by the time she first gained immortality. Because of that it is actually believable when she claims not to have any evil intentions. Still there’s enough room for doubt – due to her actions, words and more – that even to the very end, the reader can’t quite be sure whether Kalyba should be considered evil or just antagonistic.
The PoV characters are complicated to describe. Like the plot, they need a lot of time before they start to shine – that is if they shine at all. For the first half of the novel, all of them are incredibly passive and have no interest in actually furthering a plot or upsetting the status quo. This can be especially exhausting when you don’t yet have an idea where they and the plot are supposed to go.
Ead
Ead is tasked with watching over Sabran so that she doesn’t die. Therefore she mostly idles around in the palace until later on she is forced to leave and actually become active and truly investing. In the beginning, she didn’t even choose or enjoy that mission, but when she is offered to change her life situation by her ‘employer’, she effectively says: “I’d rather stay here and make sure no plot happens.”
Tané
At the start of the novel, Tané involuntarily witnesses the arrival of an illegal traveler. At this point she is still in military school and needs to make sure no one learns of her involvement with him. Her goal is literally: Don’t do anything that draws any attention to you. This becomes her main motivator for a major part of the first half. Even after she is found out, it takes her a while before she stops sulking and starts doing… anything really. Shannon herself seems to not know what to do with her at points, because she gets ignored for 70 pages and then shortly after for 100 pages.
Niclays
Niclays Roos is the worst offender of this crime. His motivation is literally to be left in peace and not be involved in any politics or plot and this doesn’t change until the end of the novel. Everywhere he goes, he has to be dragged to with a dagger held to his throat; everything he does, he does because others force him to.
Loth
Loth is the only one who has plot driving motivations in the beginning. Shame they’re always put onto him by someone else. First he gets exiled to a foreign kingdom to work as a spy and find out what's going on with the government there. Then the princess of that kingdom tasks him with delivering an important object to yet another kingdom. When he arrives at that kingdom, the plot ignores him for 130 pages until Ead comes into his vicinity and gets him back to his homeland, where he finally gets to make his own decisions.
This change from being passive to active happens for most characters pretty consistently between page 400 and 500, upon which the plot too becomes more heated. That still doesn’t mean however that all PoV characters suddenly become enjoyable or get an interesting plot to follow.
Niclays is entirely useless to the plot and could have been cut completely, were it not for the few chapters he traveled with the Golden Empress. He is mostly useless in those too, but he provided a PoV for that section of the story. In fact, chapter 69 actively plays with the fact that he has missed effectively every major plot beat, was a useless disappointment to everyone who had ever allied with him in some way (romantic, political or otherwise) and how he had let everyone down. His absolute lack of any internal motivation to do anything led him down a path where he has really not achieved anything of relevance throughout the entire novel.
Tané on the other hand gets very strong internal motivations and is very active in the latter half. Her problem is rather that she is absolutely insufferable, both before and after the 500 page mark. Her goals are all the way through absolutely self-centered and egotistic. Every life decision she makes is purely based on how it will change her standing in the world and society. Yet she never get punished for that sentiment and always comes out on top.
This starts in chapter one, where she breaks the rules because of a superstition that is said to give her a better chance of achieving a position as dragonrider, even though it is not related to any work or necessary skill. While she is doing that, she meets an illegal traveler. Instead of dealing with him herself and revealing that she broke the rules, she loads this responsibility off to a friend. If you want to be generous, you could argue that this is the one time she ever gets punished for her actions, because her friend – not she herself – is later executed and she expelled from the dragonriders. Her dragon however remains loyal to her.
Even when it comes to doing the noble or morally right thing to do like saving a sacred dragon from imprisonment or defeating a world-ending threat, she is motivated almost exclusively by the idea of redeeming herself for past sins and becoming a dragonrider again. This results in her harming other people while she tries to right her past wrongs. She steals a ship which means its crew is completely absent from the final fight against the Nameless One, where they could have helped a great deal. Instead they are trapped on an island that does not have the resources to sustain both the ship’s crew and the locals (Tané knows that). Tané has committed so many moral sins throughout the novel but not learned a single lesson to make her a better person, even though the story wants you to believe she is actually good.
Loth and Ead are much more enjoyable, which is good considering that Loth, Tané and Niclays are more side characters in Ead’s story, rather than equal protagonists. It is probably no overstatement to say that 75%-80% of the pages are dedicated to Ead’s PoV.
The Plot
The plot of the novel is generally quite good. There is a lot happening within the span of so many pages, which has several side effects, positive and negative. For one, Shannon shows really compelling changes over time with both the people and the world. It is hard to believe that the characters we got to know in the beginning are the same ones that end the story, yet when you look at the bigger picture, their developments are perfectly logical and gradual with no big leaps. Also, with so much information given at any point in time, it is very easy to hide foreshadowing or leave out game-changing information without the reader noticing. Shannon uses this with great skill and success.
An avoidable problem however, that Shannon was not able to navigate around, is that the story takes a while to truly begin. It is only after around 400 pages that the story truly starts to gain steam and become investing – a point at which many novels have already told a complete story.
Along with this comes a rather odd pacing with strangely placed high and low points in tension. It often feels like there is a lot of slow (honestly at times boring) build-up for a climactic part of the story, that then is over way sooner than it should be. One notable example of this are how Ead returns home to the South and slowly realizes that the place has changed in a way she dislikes. Simultaneously she learns of a prisoner there she wants to break out and return to the North, where a coup is happening and needs to be stopped. That section is a slog of being fed information that will eventually be relevant. The actual retaking of the Inys government however is dealt with within two chapters, though it could have easily been at least 100 pages or more.
Another noteworthy point within the plot is the final fight against the Nameless One, the world destroying evil dragon king. It doesn’t necessarily feel too short, though it is evident that Shannon did not want to linger on this action scene (or most action scenes really) for longer than needed. The spectacle of it is very engaging and the chaos of the situation is vividly described in a way that makes your adrenaline rise. You can see the light and dust, hear the screams and sense the pain and exhaustion. It is short but does in a lot of ways live up to the hype the story wants to establish.
Still, it could have been improved in certain ways. One big problem is the fact that the Priory of the Orange Tree – the people the novel was named after – does not appear once throughout the fight, even though they have prepared themselves for it for a thousand years. There are other people, e.g. Gian Harlowe, who should be there but aren’t. Tané does get some grand scenes in which her friend and dragon dramatically appear in climactic moments. Clearly Shannon knew the impact of such scenes, so why could these other people not come?
The length of the final fight may work, but the epilogue is definitely too short. Each of the four PoV characters get their own one and they are all quite nice. They have a great sense of ‘the adventure continues’, which is definitely how these characters would lead their further lives after their recent experiences. Only Niclays gets an epilogue where he finally gets to settle down and live the last years of his life in peace at home. Again, very much in character. But too many side characters are forgotten about or only hastily mentioned in a small sentence, even though several of them would be very interesting to hear about. It is not enough to just say the Donmata Marosa is alive and well. How do Roslain and Laya hold up now?
Generally, one can say: The plot is good, but the beginning is too long and the end is too short.