Take a photo of a barcode or cover
hongjoongie 's review for:
A Little Luck
by Claudia Piñeiro
hopeful
sad
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Very disappointing given how amazing Elena Knows is. The characters are one dimensional, the narrator is very dislikable, the plot is unbelievable, and the tone is melodramatic and sappy.
Worst of all, the crux of the novel (the trauma the narrator experiences) is ham fisted and becomes super repetitive. We learn pretty early on the trauma/“crime” is the narrator disregarding a railroad crossing warning, her car stalls directly on the tracks (somehow), she can’t get her child’s friend out of the car (somehow), and the train hits the car and kills him. Then we are constantly reminded of this memory very bluntly/not in an interesting way that would show how the narrator is traumatized. Just two of the MANY examples: “even if I didn’t know who they were, they’d surely know who I was: the woman who crossed the train tracks when the barrier was down and killed a little boy” and, when she comes back to the scene years later, “but to my surprise I don’t find the barrier arm that I illegally drove past only to have my car stall and get run over by a train … if by unfortunate chance a car happened to stall, no train would be able to run it over with a child trapped inside.” WE GET IT.
Even with the flaws, I never really felt the urge to stop reading, mainly because I was at first interested to find out what happened and then to see how things ended up (and the book is pretty short). Sadly I was disappointed by both and annoyed most of the time, so I don’t think this can be a 3.