illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

Listen to Your Sister by Neena Viel
3.0
adventurous dark emotional mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Calla Williams has newly become the guardian to her brother Jamie. She's struggling, overwhelmed by Jamie's sixteen-year-old recklessness, and tired of being the one making sacrifices for her family. Dre, their brother, promised to help out but in classic middle-child fashion, he's off doing his own thing. Calla is haunted by The Nightmare, a recurring dream of losing her brothers in ways she's powerless to stop, and when Jamie's actions at a protest force the siblings to skip town, The Nightmare decides to dig in its claws. 

This was a wildly imaginative story of familial trauma, sibling bonds, and identity. Viel uses speculative horror to explore how a difficult childhood can freeze a version of you in time, reliving those moments, never allowed to move on. Social commentary on race was woven in effectively, especially through Jamie, showing how a traumatised Black boy is easily dismissed as a troublemaker worthy of incarceration over help. 

Though this is a debut, I thought the dialogue was fantastic. Natural and believable, it doesn't shy away from the fact that people curse, they get angry and snap, and struggle to express their deepest thoughts. The balance of anger at her brothers for curtailing her life and her fierce love for them was so clear in the way Calla thought about and spoke to them, and their complex feelings for her also shone. 

Where this fell down was how disjointed it felt at times. The line between explanation and open-endedness is so hard to tread in a fever dream narrative, and this was wandering back and forth over it far too much. The horror elements needed a slower build but they pop up at random, and in later action scenes it could get extremely hard to keep track of who was where and what objects they were interacting with. 

For all that some parts were disjointed, never once did I doubt that these siblings loved and infuriated each other, or that their bonds had been forged in something darker than blood. 

Thank you Titan Books for sending this to me!