I have mixed feelings about this book. I liked the plot, characters and worldbuilding, and there were parts of the book I really enjoyed. On the other hand, there were scenes I didn't like, moments that felt rushed, other parts that felt too long. The atmosphere wasn't quite there and it didn't grip me. 

It is the author's first book as well as the first in the series, and it's entirely possible that future books will appeal to me more. I can certainly think of series I love where I was equally unsure about book one. 

The cover is beautiful, and the Goldsboro edition is absolutely stunning. There are plenty of illustrations, and while Chris Riddell's style has never been quite to my taste, it does suit the story very well. 

Lots of potential and I may well decide to get book two, I just didn't quite love it.