francesmthompson's profile picture

francesmthompson 's review for:

Girl on a Train by A.J. Waines
1.0

I wanted to read this book because I'd read about how the other book of a similar name had actually catapulted this book to the top of the Amazon Kindle charts because people kept downloading it by mistake. I subsequently wanted this book to then be better than the other one. But it wasn't. It really, really wasn't.
So yes, I finished this book, because yes, it had me hooked in terms of wanting to know what happened, but ultimately I wanted to see if the book and author would redeem themselves. You see, after plodding along quite nicely through the first half, my only gripe was that the story badly needed an editor and about half as many words. But then I began to feel quite angry about some of the stances the characters and ultimately the author took, not least the offensive views that
Spoilerrape is a crime you can ignore in order to find some good in a person (!!!!)
and
Spoilerbeing gay is a shameful thing that would have you thrown out of the Met police
. It also had the most bizarre use of a church to create a community of characters (the majority of which didn't seem to be church-going types at all, see married man having multiple affairs with women much younger than him) and the fact that
Spoiler two completely separate stories and circumstance became so inextricably linked
really did make me almost laugh in disbelief.
All these scathing things said, I was surprised by The Big Reveal and didn't find it completely unthinkable or lacking in feasibility... albeit a stretch of the imagination.
But when all is said and done the previously mentioned viewpoints on issues we shouldn't mess around with, even in fiction, unless sensitively done so, means this is my first 1 star book of the year.