Take a photo of a barcode or cover
chrisssl 's review for:
Men at Arms
by Terry Pratchett
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
This book is a noticeable step down from Guards, Guards, having fewer jokes that really nail it along with more digressions but without any of the incisive commentary or subtext that the best of Discworld novels are known for.
This is decidedly NOT a piece of biting satire. One may be tempted to read more into the novel's treatment around ethnic tensions and gun violence, but the reader would be left disappointed. These are more jokes than well-developed sources of painful ironic truths. The setting here works against any stronger thematic purpose to them and the trying to view the novel in this light leaves it feeling clumsy. Clearly, not every novel, not even a Pratchett one need have some real insight into the world hidden beneath the British humour, onomatopoeia and fantasy, though most of his best are.
This is a fairly brisk read though it feels meandering and aimless at times, reflecting how our once protagonist Sam Vimes who has been relegated to perhaps a quarter of the story. In his place steps Corporal Carrot who was a great side character though his starling optimism seems less satisfying to follow as a lead than was Vimes' nihilistic righteous outrage.
This is the first true sequel book I've read in the Discworld so it may just be that, but Ankh-Mopork and the general setting feel less exciting, and I feel the prose has gotten sparser and less illustrative, almost relying on a reading of Guards, Guards to implicitly fill in details which are underwritten (ie: the foundations of the city).
There is still some humor to redeem it but I think this one goes down as a pretty mediocre followup to the brilliant: Guards, Guards!
This is decidedly NOT a piece of biting satire. One may be tempted to read more into the novel's treatment around ethnic tensions and gun violence, but the reader would be left disappointed. These are more jokes than well-developed sources of painful ironic truths. The setting here works against any stronger thematic purpose to them and the trying to view the novel in this light leaves it feeling clumsy. Clearly, not every novel, not even a Pratchett one need have some real insight into the world hidden beneath the British humour, onomatopoeia and fantasy, though most of his best are.
This is a fairly brisk read though it feels meandering and aimless at times, reflecting how our once protagonist Sam Vimes who has been relegated to perhaps a quarter of the story. In his place steps Corporal Carrot who was a great side character though his starling optimism seems less satisfying to follow as a lead than was Vimes' nihilistic righteous outrage.
This is the first true sequel book I've read in the Discworld so it may just be that, but Ankh-Mopork and the general setting feel less exciting, and I feel the prose has gotten sparser and less illustrative, almost relying on a reading of Guards, Guards to implicitly fill in details which are underwritten (ie: the foundations of the city).
There is still some humor to redeem it but I think this one goes down as a pretty mediocre followup to the brilliant: Guards, Guards!