alixmcinally's profile picture

alixmcinally 's review for:

Vows & Ruins by Helen Scheuerer
3.0
adventurous medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

okay i did enjoy this book, but definitely not as much as the first one. i absolutely loved this book, all the way up until about 75%.

first off, there were a lot of positives about this book! once again, the side characters were amazing, and i loved some of the “family” scenes we got with all of them together.

i really enjoyed thea’s development, and i loved seeing how much she progressed as a warrior!

the plot overall was really good, and i enjoyed how smoothly it continued on from the first book.

overall, a really solid beginning and middle where i felt invested and intrigued!

then there’s the criticisms. overall, i really liked the romance and loved seeing thea and wilder get closer and admit their feelings to one another, but there were wayyyy too many intimate scenes. i’m not sure if this was just me, but it literally felt like there was one every other chapter, to the point where i actually wanted to skip through them because i was so over it. i don’t mind some spice in a book, but it really ruins the meaning and the emotion behind it when it’s happening alllll the time. i wished we had got to see some sweeter scenes with perhaps some more dialogue to balance it out, as i absolutely loved the banter and dialogue between them in the first book. definitely spice overkill which really distracted from the plot unfortunately🫠

my other criticism is that the ending felt soooo rushed. i also said this about the first book, but this time it really impacted my enjoyment after finishing it. it felt like there was absolutely no build up at all to the plot twist at the end, and it came completely out of left field. now some people might say that’s how plot twists are supposed to be, but i disagree. i always enjoy it when i can look back and see some hints or signs that i missed, but with this i can’t see anything at all that indicated the plot twist!
(the one with the daughter of darkness being their sister was good as i had actually predicted it and i felt like it had been hinted at in a good way), however, the one with hawthorne seemed like it totally came out of nowhere. it was obvious that he was hiding things, some of which even the reader wasn’t aware of, but there was absolutely no indication that he was in league with the daughter of darkness. i just felt so confused after reading that, cause it wasn’t built up at all it was kind of just dropped and then the book ended. and i felt like thea’s reaction was sooo underwhelming. like she didn’t even seem that mad???


overall, i did still enjoy this book, all the way up until the end! i’ll still continue the series i think because i’m invested now, but i hope some of these issues get fixed in the next book🫣