Good but not great

I really liked the idea that this book set out to tell but it was a little muddled along the way book was still interesting though. I liked the characters especially Julianna and Warren both were interesting characters in their own ways a girl who wants to go outside and a boy that was interesting in his own way. The other characters were ok the villains and many of the other characters were campy not uninteresting though I liked reading about them. The plot was interesting for the most part it told a little too much and showed not quite enough so the story starts with a curse it's goes to other things like a traveling troupe and really oddly specific things I liked though.

Merged review:

Good but not great

I really liked the idea that this book set out to tell but it was a little muddled along the way book was still interesting though. I liked the characters especially Julianna and Warren both were interesting characters in their own ways a girl who wants to go outside and a boy that was interesting in his own way. The other characters were ok the villains and many of the other characters were campy not uninteresting though I liked reading about them. The plot was interesting for the most part it told a little too much and showed not quite enough so the story starts with a curse it's goes to other things like a traveling troupe and really oddly specific things I liked though.