orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

5.0
challenging emotional hopeful inspiring reflective tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

tldr/summary:
A deeply character-driven story that grabs your emotions a surprising lot despite its shortness. It is both deeply sad and very uplifting. Overall a joy to read. 

Long version:
Billie Scott has the mission to draw 10 interesting people. Needless to say the plot is not really there and just an excuse to throw Billie into scenarios where she meets people. These people however are the heart of the novel. They capture you quickly with their own stories and personalities despite some of them having very limited appearances.
While I cannot speak for how realistic the portrayal of homelessness is - much less in London - the world and the people's struggles do feel very real and tragic. The story explores a wide variety of fates and mentalities towards those.

Billie Scott herself is also a well executed character, though her impending blindness feels like it's forgotten about a lot of the time. What is interesting is that it was caused by her extremely antisocial and self-destructive lifestyle, though it could have been pushed a bit more towards the "It happened because you live so terribly and alone." line of things, for example being a result of malnutrition and lack of going outside rather than an encounter with dangerous people in that outside world she's supposed to go to. 
Either way, she is now pushed to get out into the unknown before it's too late, which is a good way to make her tragedy feel real and with consequence.

However once Billie sets her feet into the first train, her condition takes a back seat and is only really brought up when it has to be and at the very end when she is full blind.
It would have been interesting for example if the black spots in her vision are visible to the reader all the time and become more as her condition gets worse, though that would get difficult when she is full blind for the last 20 or so pages.

The overall tone of the novel is very uplifting as we see a lot of characters living in terrible situations in a deeply flawed world and making the best out of them. This makes the whole experience very pleasant and even wholesome despite its dark themes, but it does get a bit overly cheesy at the very end.