You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

aeonwren 's review for:

Authority by Jeff VanderMeer
2.0

Such a frustrating read. I can't shake the sense that there's a good book somewhere in here. But it's not this one.

Maybe it's to do with the fact that all three initial books in the Southern Reach series were released in quick succession (although that doesn't necessarily mean they were written in quick succession). Maybe it's the usual phenomenon where the first book in a trilogy is edited much more strictly than its successors. Or it's just the typical slump a lot of trilogies experience towards the middle.

But this feels unfinished. Hastily put together and badly edited. A far cry from the prose I so enjoyed in Annihilation.


It doesn't help that the main character and narrator, John Rodriguez aka Control, is both unlikable and inept. Nepotism got him his job as the new director of the Southern Reach, and even as an experienced operative (albeit not a successful one) he will whine incessantly throughout the novel that his higher-ups do not tell him precisely what they are up to.

I've always thought that sort of thing was normal in any hierarchical institution, but what do I know.

Sent to analyze the investigation into Area X, Rodriguez soaks up any and all information presented to him, retains little, and never exhibits anything akin to critical thinking. A side character introduces the concept of terroir, and Rodriguez promptly adopts it as part of his belief system, then misapplies the term throughout the rest of the novel. Another side character explains basic multiverse theory, and somehow this is treated as a fresh idea. As a theme, terroir especially feels both clunky and underdeveloped.

I saw it coming a mile away, but when Rodriguez finds out that he, too, has been hypnotized by the institution that routinely hypnotizes people (it's a big plot point in Annihilation, and arguably one of the weakest ones), he throws a fit and goes on a weekend-long bender. If there is a more subtle insight to be had here about his nickname and his loss of control due to hypnosis, it's lost in the absurdity of his tantrum.

I also would have enjoyed the book a lot more if the narration hadn't explained every single dialogue beat to me. Every single time.

Let me infer things.

Let me draw my own conclusions.

But no, at every moment, I am taken by the hand and have things explained to me. I kept hoping for a larger payoff, a smidgen of unreliable narration at least. But no.

This is almost twice as long as Annihilation, and a good third of it is bloat.