“Thou believest too much in thine intellect as a woman.”

Throughout time, one of the most dangerous of creatures has been a woman able to think freely and intelligently.  Bohjalian has delivered a spell-binding, often maddening look at the turmoil caused by gossip and fear in 17th century Puritan Boston.  

Mary’s circumstances matter not in her Puritan community.  She is married to a dangerous man, prone to drink and ready with a fist.  But because he is a needed and profitable businessman, she is expected to lie about the bruises upon her cheek.  When at last, she can no longer continue with the ruse, she seeks divorce.  But logic and reason are overtaken by town gossip, harsh scrutinization, and ludicrous accusations. 

Bohjalian has masterfully created a slow burn mixture of historical fiction and mystery that I couldn’t put down.  The time period and Puritan lifestyle are skillfully portrayed, as is the intricate development of the characters.  This adept execution creates mounting tension in anticipation of Mary’s fate.  

The message of this book is timeless, thought provoking, and important. It also reminded me, from history until today, that fear has often overwhelmed reason.  

Thank you Chris Bohjalian, Doubleday Books, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an advanced copy of this book