A witch who is looking for her soulmate reconnects with the merman who broke her heart. Lucinda “Lucy” Caraway adores living in Frey Grove, a mystic seaside town filled with magical beings. She spends her days as a high school history teacher and works as a tea reader too, but despite all of this she yearns for something more, she wants true love. After a night of drunken fun with her friends they accidentally all make wishes... and hers was for excitement... and suddenly Alex Dwyer is back in her life. Alex Dwyer, the merman who was her best friend and crush all throughout high school who broke her heart and left without so much as a second look back. Alex Dwyer is a merman, constantly on the move and ready to explore and chase his next exciting adventure. Ever since he could remember he has hated the idea of being tied down and he has wanted to escape Freya Grove as soon as possible, even if it meant leaving behind the one person who made him feel something else and messing it up. Now he is back in town to celebrate his birthday with his family and he runs into the one person he can’t keep out of his head and the one person he wants to get a second chance with. To Alex’s surprise his parents bought him a house for his birthday... a house that symbolizes settling down in the one place he didn’t ever see himself settling down, but then he runs into Lucy and coincidentally the house his parents bought is right across the street from him.. so what better way to spend time with Lucy then convincing her to help him get the house ready to be sold off... yet the more time they spend together the more he finds himself wanting to settle down and wanting to be with Lucy. Yet with old hurts and fears can they truly make it? Lucy wants someone who will want to be with her, to stay with her... and she knows Alex wants to be free and doesn’t want to settle yet he keeps drawing her in... can this summer fling be something more or is it meant to come and go just like the waves? Can Lucy trust Alex with her heart and can Alex prove to her that she’s what he’s been looking for? This was a cute witchy romance and the perfect cute seaside town romance!

*Thank you Forever Publishing and Grand Central Books for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review*