You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
illustrated_librarian 's review for:
Fair Play
by Louise Hegarty
medium-paced
In the country house Airbnb Abigail has found to host her and her brother Benjamin's traditional New Year's murder mystery party, an evening of fun, games, and drinking begins. By and large the event is a success and the guests happily totter to bed afterwards. The next morning everyone wakes up, apart from Benjamin. Suddenly, all is not what it seems. An eminent detective arrives, the house has a staff it didn't before, and this is now a locked-room mystery where everyone is a suspect.
This is a formally experimental and heavily metafictional novel, using the mechanics of Golden Age mysteries to explore the process of grief.
Hegarty clearly knows the mystery canon well and this is incredibly self-aware, more so even than Knives Out and the like. Think a detective and sidekick who seem completely aware they're in a novel: confident they'll solve certain things by chapter 23, referencing a funny feeling they had back in chapter 4, or ruling out suspicions using the rules of writing classic detective fiction that Hegarty inserts between the first and second section of the book.
It's a bold concept and I could see how Hegarty was aiming to represent the way Abigail's world is suddenly, literally, split in two by grief. It lays bare the deeply human need to find meaning and patterns where sometimes there are simply none, or none we can know for certain.
Unfortunately, I don't think a good concept is enough to carry an entire novel and in parts it began to work against itself. Because of the metafictional element the detective sections began to feel empty and mechanical, the reveals about the suspects unsurprising because they're standard mystery plot points, and the emotional depth lacking as everyone felt like a bit player. The sections in the present with Abigail grieving were compassionate, but the two strands never came together to make something greater than the sum of their parts.
This is, for me, a good piece of craft, but not a good story. Does that make sense?
Thank you to Picador for sending me a proof in exchange for an honest review!
This is a formally experimental and heavily metafictional novel, using the mechanics of Golden Age mysteries to explore the process of grief.
Hegarty clearly knows the mystery canon well and this is incredibly self-aware, more so even than Knives Out and the like. Think a detective and sidekick who seem completely aware they're in a novel: confident they'll solve certain things by chapter 23, referencing a funny feeling they had back in chapter 4, or ruling out suspicions using the rules of writing classic detective fiction that Hegarty inserts between the first and second section of the book.
It's a bold concept and I could see how Hegarty was aiming to represent the way Abigail's world is suddenly, literally, split in two by grief. It lays bare the deeply human need to find meaning and patterns where sometimes there are simply none, or none we can know for certain.
Unfortunately, I don't think a good concept is enough to carry an entire novel and in parts it began to work against itself. Because of the metafictional element the detective sections began to feel empty and mechanical, the reveals about the suspects unsurprising because they're standard mystery plot points, and the emotional depth lacking as everyone felt like a bit player. The sections in the present with Abigail grieving were compassionate, but the two strands never came together to make something greater than the sum of their parts.
This is, for me, a good piece of craft, but not a good story. Does that make sense?
Thank you to Picador for sending me a proof in exchange for an honest review!