You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

stephsbooktalk's profile picture

stephsbooktalk 's review for:

A Winter in New York by Josie Silver
3.75

Mini Audiobook Review: 3.75 - Even though I did the audio of this, I did win this book as a GoodReads giveaway!

This was my one book club pick for the month of December but we ended up talking more about one of the other choices this month. It is not like this was a bad book by all means it just wasn't a favorite of mine that I have read this book. I will say I think I did enjoy this one more than One Day in December.  I'd like to think that Gio wouldn't have been THAT upset with her over the secret that she has kept from him. And I feel like he wasn't that upset by it if my memory serves correctly. I know Josie's other book was picked up for adaptation but I would much rather see this one adapted. All the characters minus the ex boyfriend were entertaining enough.

I am glad I did the audiobook for this as opposed to reading. I thought the narrator was great and brought Iris's delicateness to the story.

PS - I really need to give gelato a try!

Swoon: 3/10
Karaoke: sadly no