#1: 4/5. it took me a while to get into this but by the end i was invested in the characters!!

#2: 3.75/5. this suffered a little bit from second book syndrome. it was just so slow. i still like the characters, and the last 50% was compelling, but it kind of felt like a really long book where not much happened

#3: 4.25/5. at first, i wasn’t jiving w the multiple povs, but i appreciated it by the end. some parts of this felt too slow, but the writing was really good. i am really attached to these characters. they feel like old friends. i wish the end provided a little more closure about their live