You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

abandonedquests's profile picture

abandonedquests 's review for:

The Broken Girls by Simone St. James
5.0

I really enjoyed The Broken Girls, my second novel by Simone St. James. Her brand of mystery in two timelines, with a splash of ghost story, is such a perfect fall comfort read.

I read a lot of mysteries and St. James stands out for her characters (wonderfully engaging female characters in particular, but even her supporting male characters, such as Fiona's father and boyfriend, are well written and interesting) and the way she paints a time period: the characters and settings in the past and present really do feel different, and the world of Idlewild Hall is immersive.

The mystery also kept me engaged and guessing -- it was twisty but with a conclusion that made perfect sense from how she'd written the characters, and thematically heartbreaking in places. Just a great story all around.