First reread, June/July 2017: 5 stars.

I never thought this would happen, but this has replaced Anna as my new favorite in the trilogy. It was so cute and I honestly can't think of any cringeworthy moments. In my opinion, the story was full of awkward, relatable moments rather than cringeworthy ones. And as much as I like Anna, it made me cringe sometimes. Anyway. I could relate so much to Isla, even Josh at times, and I felt for them both. They need hugs and also they're absolutely adorable. Awkward, unsure, passionate. Yes please. I used to think they made up too easily, but now I think it was perfect. And the best part of the book was the reunion/meeting of all seven of them - Anna, Étienne, Mer, Lola, Cricket, Isla, and Josh - don't fight me on this. The following scene was the cutest EVER, don't fight me on this either. If I had to wish for one thing to be different, I'd wish for an epilogue about all of them. Otherwise, I have to say it was honestly perfect. This is my new favorite in the trilogy. ❤️

(If any of you are curious, for me it's Isla, Anna, Lola, though I love all three.)

Original read, early 2016: 4.5 stars

I loved this book. It was fun, cute, and enjoyable, and the characters were great. My favorite parts were the reunion/meeting and what came right after. I just think that Isla and Josh made up too easily, and I wish there had been an epilogue.

* full review on my blog :)