orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

Yellowface by R.F. Kuang
4.0
informative mysterious tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

tldr/summary:
The novel has a very interesting premise that is very well executed with a marvelous (dislikeable) protagonist. The image of the publishing industry that the author wants to convey to the reader is woven into the plot with a lot of elegance, though it focuses more on the social media aspect of publishing than the industry itself.
However there are a few plot beats that are very contrived and hard to believe as realistic; it is very obvious that they would never happen, were they not necessary for the plot. The story also gets a bit repetitive in the middle section. 

Long version:
The first thing I noticed was how easy to read the text was, how colloquial and natural. It feels less like a distinguished, intellectual literary novel and more like some actual white woman ramblings. The style is fitting for the story and marvelously executed. The pages just fly by.

Which brings us directly to the next outstanding point: the protagonist. June Hayward is incredibly dislikeable and it's hard to understand how R F Kuang made a character so enjoyably evil. And the way the character tries to rationalize her behavior also feels very real and believable. This is such a perfect parody of a white woman. The only thing to hold "against" her is that she put more research into Chinese history than a real (white) person in her situation would have.

Said situation of how she came into possession of an unpublished bestseller manuscript and how Athena died is very construed and its very hard to suspend your disbelief about it. But in the end it is just means to an end of telling the actual story. It is only a neglectable fraction of the overall story.

The main focus of the first part of the novel is how June takes Athena's work to rise to fame in the world of literature. While this part does give some nice insight into how the book publishing industry works with its agents, publishing companies, going over second and third drafts, the main focus later shifts to dealing with social media as a celebrity. It also feels a bit rushed. The specifics of the industry were not very detailed. 
This in itself is fine, however it does start to feel repetitive after some time, since there's at least three separate shitstorms June has to deal with and the solution is always: "Ignore it until the mob's attention shifts to something else they can hate.". 

Throughout the novel, there's a certain element of mystery and hints at possible supernatural activities. At first it's a bit jarring but only ever a side note on the page. It makes sense within June's fear-and-guilt-ridden mind and her denial over her (a)morality. She is an incredibly unreliable narrator (and one of the best executions of this technique), so it makes sense that she sees things that aren't there. Especially since she's an artist, who tend to have a particularly vivid imagination.
This subplot however evolves into the main focus of the final act where the suspension of disbelief completely breaks and the story turns from "This could have actually happened in real life." to obviously fictional.

The final pages of the story and the ultimate resolution of the plot however are exceptional. It is both the perfect resolution for June's character development as well as the existential-dread ridden publishing world the novel paints. It is very satisfying although the steps necessary to get there were rather jarring. Just like the beginning is a necessary evil for an interesting story, the final act is contrived to give a satisfying ending.