ellemnope's profile picture

ellemnope 's review for:

Such a Fun Age by Kiley Reid
4.0

An impactful book from a unique point of view. While most of the racial bias type of novels I have read seem to have centered on the fallout in general after a racially charged event, Such a Fun Age focuses on the close circle of those involved/affected without any direct impact from public opinion (this does not mean that perceived public opinion does not play a definite role in this book). I liked this approach, as the "main event" certainly has its place and focus, but the real guts of the story stay in a very close sphere, allowing the characters to really demonstrate their own personal reactions based solely on their own personalities, experiences, and views.

There was a big cringe factor for me in this book on several levels, as we watch people just making horrible assumptions and failing to look at the big picture. I was particularly disappointed in the characters of Alix and Kelly, but also recognize that they absolutely represent people who do exist in society. The portrayal of misguided actions is very well done, while still being realistically subtle. In fact, realism was executed well from beginning to end. While I found the ending sad for several reasons, it was so amazingly real. Life doesn't always turn out sunshine and roses and not everyone learns from their mistakes or handles missteps appropriately. I applaud Reid's willingness to create an ending that may not have pleased all of her readers, but that presented a more "real life" kind of example.

I was minorly disappointed in the execution of some of the characters. I wish that there had been a slightly different approach to the portrayal of Emira's friend group. These individuals were supposed to be in their mid-to-late 20's, but the overall vibe was a bit more immature than I would have expected. I would have appreciated a more balanced approach to these characters (instead of only portraying them only as partiers). I also wish that Alix would have been given some kind of redeeming quality. Though her narcissism is at the core of who she is, it would have been good to see her having something that didn't just make her look so far to the side of "bad rich white lady". A little complexity could have made her an even more identifiable and realistic character.