This was fun. I've always admired detective stories. I don't know if the clues are set up in a way that the average reader can deduce and figure out what's happening, but I had fun reading. Holmes and Watson's banter is great, and there are constant twists and turns.

The artwork is supposed to have a gritty feel, but some panels look unfinished due to the sketchy line art. The last issue has a "hamster eyes" problem where they're too spaced out and pupil-less. One of the side characters Junior is supposed to be a young teenager but looks like he's pushing 50. Despite these minor things, I think the artwork was mostly effective, and I believe the New York setting.

I was really intrigued by Holmes. What's driving him? The sense of accomplishment, the need to do good, his mother's approval, etc? This question may be enough to make me read the second volume.