maxarcreads's profile picture

maxarcreads 's review for:

Of Jade and Dragons by Amber Chen
3.5

3.5 for me.

There were a lot of things I did enjoy about the book, the premise, the characters and plot with lots of tropes I enjoy. But as much there was to love about the book, I was just not able to fully immerse myself in it. It was a pleasant read, but it was not an exciting read where I had trouble putting it down. I think that it might be that at times the writing felt very surface level. I think there were some missed opportunities to really make this silk punk fantasy world and the scenes jump off the pages. Such as the time spent at the Engineers gild. The was a main part of the book and what Ying had always dreamed of joining but had not been allowed simply because she was a woman. Her time going through the trials which last like 6mo if I remember correctly but we never really delve into her time other than one or two instances in-between the trials which were definitely interesting to read. It's just the way this book was described made it seem like a strong competition academia setting and while I did get the competition feel during the trials there was no time in-between to build up the anticipation of the upcoming trial, the back and forth fighting as you fight for what may be only one opening in the guild or even the making of alliances to help each other through the trials which you normally see in competition academic books. Also, this was portrayed as having Mulan influences which I can definitely see but what I loved about that movie was all the near misses Mulan had where her identity/gender may have been discovered drove up the nerves as well made for some comical moments. While there were instances where Ying was at risk of being discovered they just didn't feel the same way. They just felt to easily worked around or solved. 

Overall, I enjoyed the premise of the book and what I think the author was trying to convey when it came to showing the consequences of ambition and how the things we create can have everlasting destruction which makes sense with this being centered around engineers and the creations they make that will go towards the war effort. I found the book to be a pleasant easy book to read just not the most exciting one. 

This book is about Ying who dreamed of following in her father's footsteps and joining the engineer's guild but was unable to due to her gender. So, she instead spends her time coming up with her own inventions and testing them out under the supervision of her father. That is until one day when coming back from testing an invention she stumbles in on the unaliving of her father by an a$$asin. All she has left is the journal her father commanded her to destroy and the pendant of the man who unalived her father. Using this and some other clues leads to her assuming her younger brother identify and setting out to the capital to join the engineer's gild as all clues seem to point to there and her father's past there that he had kept hidden from her. With the help of an expected ally in the form of a prince, she is able to join as in the trials to join the guild so that she may uncover these secrets her father kept hidden from her and what about it was worth unaliving him for. That is if she can pass the trials while keeping her identity hidden because if she were to be found out it would mean dire consequences for her. 

I received an ARC copy from netgalley in exchange for an honest review.