Take a photo of a barcode or cover
ashlightgrayson 's review for:
Tears We Cannot Stop: A Sermon to White America
by Michael Eric Dyson
challenging
informative
medium-paced
I won this book a while ago in a giveaway and I'm glad I was finally able to finally finish it. The book addresses various aspects of how being white in America garners more opportunities and spares white people from a lot of the hardships that come with being black. The author speaks directly to the reader and the writing style can make the message seem preachy, but you have to keep in mind that the book was intentionally written in the style of a sermon. I know some people might not be fans of that, but it does get the message across. The book balances out the use of personal anecdotes, historical events and court cases to use as arguments for how some white people often do not fully understand the events that have led to black communities as a whole to be disenfranchised and disadvantaged in many ways. The author provides an empathetic view of why crime and incarceration rates tend to be higher in these communities and how white people continue to play an active role in maintaining this as the status quo, even if unintentionally.
There are certain portions of the book that I do not necessarily agree with and I will explain them because I think they are extremely relevant and important when speaking about race as a social construct. At some point the author differentiates between black Americans and black immigrants in America. The argument he makes is that black immigrants have, and I quote: "arrived from societies where they enjoyed equality without regard to color. Thus they arrive with great assets, skills , and experiences, allowing them to compete in the American marketplace." My father and his entire side of the family is black Cuban and I am also black and a first generation American in the United States. My paternal great grandmother was a white Spanish woman who married a black man and went on to have children with him. When breastfeeding her black child she would often get racist comments such as "why are you breastfeeding your servant's child". My mother is from Honduras and there is also racial prejudice present in Central America. Interracial couplings with a darker skinned partners are often looked down upon in Latin American countries because there is a lot of colorism. As a results, if your skin is lighter there are more opportunities granted to you in society because you are perceived as "whiter". This is a concept the author even makes reference to much earlier in the text in fact. Racial prejudice exists in other parts of the world besides the U.S. and I am not sure why the author would phrase the text in a way that suggests that he believes otherwise. It is possible that he was solely referring to immigrants from countries with a largely black populace. However, if that was the case it was not clear at all from the text and I think that was a huge oversight by the editing team and the author. Even if that were the case, there are multiple examples of racial prejudice affecting the quality of life and opportunities offered to black people in those countries. One of the more popularly known cases is apartheid in South Africa. While on this topic the author also suggests that foreign black people are more well tolerated by white people than black Americans. I can't vouch for the accuracy of that statement considering the number of cases of racism that there are against non-English speaking immigrants in the U.S. (largely in the Latinx community). I can't imagine that being black makes situations like that any better, but I can only speak from my perspective. I wish the author had expanded more on that so I could better understand what they were referring to or even used more specific examples. As a reader I can only opine that it was unclear to me and I think that it lacked the topic lacked the depth it needed to be clear to the audience.
Overall, I think the book offers some much needed perspective on race. I would think that the audience picking up this book already has as interest in learning about how race affects black Americans and how white people play a role in that. This book definitely addresses that appropriately and there is something to be learned by reading this. I would take my critique above into consideration when reading though because I do believe there is more space to explore what it means to be black in America outside of the black American perspective.
There are certain portions of the book that I do not necessarily agree with and I will explain them because I think they are extremely relevant and important when speaking about race as a social construct. At some point the author differentiates between black Americans and black immigrants in America. The argument he makes is that black immigrants have, and I quote: "arrived from societies where they enjoyed equality without regard to color. Thus they arrive with great assets, skills , and experiences, allowing them to compete in the American marketplace." My father and his entire side of the family is black Cuban and I am also black and a first generation American in the United States. My paternal great grandmother was a white Spanish woman who married a black man and went on to have children with him. When breastfeeding her black child she would often get racist comments such as "why are you breastfeeding your servant's child". My mother is from Honduras and there is also racial prejudice present in Central America. Interracial couplings with a darker skinned partners are often looked down upon in Latin American countries because there is a lot of colorism. As a results, if your skin is lighter there are more opportunities granted to you in society because you are perceived as "whiter". This is a concept the author even makes reference to much earlier in the text in fact. Racial prejudice exists in other parts of the world besides the U.S. and I am not sure why the author would phrase the text in a way that suggests that he believes otherwise. It is possible that he was solely referring to immigrants from countries with a largely black populace. However, if that was the case it was not clear at all from the text and I think that was a huge oversight by the editing team and the author. Even if that were the case, there are multiple examples of racial prejudice affecting the quality of life and opportunities offered to black people in those countries. One of the more popularly known cases is apartheid in South Africa. While on this topic the author also suggests that foreign black people are more well tolerated by white people than black Americans. I can't vouch for the accuracy of that statement considering the number of cases of racism that there are against non-English speaking immigrants in the U.S. (largely in the Latinx community). I can't imagine that being black makes situations like that any better, but I can only speak from my perspective. I wish the author had expanded more on that so I could better understand what they were referring to or even used more specific examples. As a reader I can only opine that it was unclear to me and I think that it lacked the topic lacked the depth it needed to be clear to the audience.
Overall, I think the book offers some much needed perspective on race. I would think that the audience picking up this book already has as interest in learning about how race affects black Americans and how white people play a role in that. This book definitely addresses that appropriately and there is something to be learned by reading this. I would take my critique above into consideration when reading though because I do believe there is more space to explore what it means to be black in America outside of the black American perspective.