I'm struggling with this one. I think it's more a 3.5.

This is a redemption story really. And it frustrated me because I felt it could have been so much more. There was depth and nuance in part and then there were lazy stereotypes that felt written for a Western audience.

Obviously the main character was unlikeable, that's kind of the point of a redemption story. But that Hassan was just so pure and spotless and sacrificing was a bit much. The 'villian' was really two dimensional and not really explored fully.

I enjoyed the relationship between Amir and his father and overall I enjoyed the story but it was too neat. I guess the ending was hopeful, but bordered on the twee.

It was sad to read about the general going back after the Taliban were removed - given they are back in power again now.