This has been my least favorite of the series. The A plot follows the Ham brothers arriving in the island to get even with Charlie for the death of their brother. The B plot follows a death in the island of one of Dot's neighbors's son. While the book was still fun, I thought that Jake was way too willing to break the law and look past stuff because of Charlie. I also didn't get why Charlie would tell Jake anything that could jeopardize his career. She is way too willing to put his entire life and her friends' lives on the line because of something she could just keep to herself.