You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon
4.0

I am incredibly torn between giving this book 3 stars and 4 stars. I'd like to note that for me, a 3-star rating is still a good book on my shelf.

I want to give this book 4 stars because it has everything I could want from a fantasy novel: dragons, romance, an epic battle, tough-decisions, long journeys, friendship and hello, duh, strong female leaders. And the ending was so satisfying. Everything was tied up nicely and I was happy with where everyone ended up. I felt like each character ended up making decisions and landing somewhere that stayed true to their personality.

But all that happens at the end of the book. And this is why I wanted to give it 3 stars: the beginning of the book was simply not as strong as the last half. Samantha Shannon dives straight into the action, which isn't necessarily bad as it drives the book forward, however she does so at the loss of explaining any background to the world you are diving into. The reader is introduced to too many different characters, worlds, cultures, ideas and languages at once. It's overwhelming and I only stuck with the novel because I had heard such good things about the rest of it. It takes almost the first half the book for everything to really start to make sense and for me to feel comfortable with everything going on and follow who was who. I can understand why some people would give up early on.

The pacing is also super weird in this novel. Shannon skips a lot of time, which is fine for the training the two main characters must face or the long stretch of time some people spend at sea or in the dessert. But the battle also went by really quickly, and since we just sat through all that build up I kind of wanted to live in it a little more.

That being said, I think I landed on 4 stars simply because I got towards the end of the book and had a hard time putting it down to eat dinner, get ready for bed and go to sleep. I wanted to keep reading! I needed to know what happens next! The end of this novel flew by. I would look at the page numbers and somehow I had read another 50 to 100 pages in seemingly a few minutes! And that's all I really want from a novel: to get lost in the story.