I really loved this book A.G Howard never disappoints I always love her books. I really liked the characters especially Rune and Thorn I really liked hoe their romance was developed and I really liked the other characters as well like Sunny and Rune's other friends they were all very well written. I really loved the story even though I know very little about the phantom of the opera I really enjoyed all aspects of this story very much. So overall I really enjoyed reading this book and will read more by this author.