Take a photo of a barcode or cover
wart 's review for:
Grimm: The Icy Touch
by John Shirley
I have so many issues with this book. I'm a big fan of media tie in novels, they can be fun and nice, quick,relaxing reads. When done well. This was not done well.
I can't believe that the author has seen more than a few episodes of Grimm. Probably first season episodes, with a summary of what goes on in season 2. Because, characterization wise, I felt like this book wanted to be set in season 1, but the author also wanted Hank to be involved in the wesen side of things, and so needed it to be in season 2.
Furthermore, the characterizations are so shaky. Sometimes they're fine, but most of the time? They don't read like the characters I know and love from the TV show. The last straw was when Hank and Nick made a rape joke. Hank, maybe I can buy, but probably not since his best friend is dating Juliette, who would never let either of them make a rape joke and not get chewed out for being insensitive ass nuggets.
But since Juliette and Rosalee felt shoehorned into this book anyway, I don't think the author gives a shit. They definitely didn't read like the characters I know and love. Juliette and Rosalee are strong, independent women. In this book, that doesn't come across. At all. When they're even in it. Which isn't often.
Also, can I just ask, who the hell believes thatNick's mom would lose the coins? Really? That she would put them in a safety deposit box that could be robbed? 'Cause I sure as hell don't believe it. Her husband and a friend died because of those coins! Author, you needed to do a better job convincing me that Denswoz got them away from her
So. Yeah. Not a well done media tie in. At all. I think I need to go rewatch some Grimm to cleanse my brain of this.
I can't believe that the author has seen more than a few episodes of Grimm. Probably first season episodes, with a summary of what goes on in season 2. Because, characterization wise, I felt like this book wanted to be set in season 1, but the author also wanted Hank to be involved in the wesen side of things, and so needed it to be in season 2.
Furthermore, the characterizations are so shaky. Sometimes they're fine, but most of the time? They don't read like the characters I know and love from the TV show. The last straw was when Hank and Nick made a rape joke. Hank, maybe I can buy, but probably not since his best friend is dating Juliette, who would never let either of them make a rape joke and not get chewed out for being insensitive ass nuggets.
But since Juliette and Rosalee felt shoehorned into this book anyway, I don't think the author gives a shit. They definitely didn't read like the characters I know and love. Juliette and Rosalee are strong, independent women. In this book, that doesn't come across. At all. When they're even in it. Which isn't often.
Also, can I just ask, who the hell believes that
So. Yeah. Not a well done media tie in. At all. I think I need to go rewatch some Grimm to cleanse my brain of this.