eatsleepromance's profile picture

eatsleepromance 's review for:

You Deserve Each Other by Sarah Hogle
4.0

I feel a little conflicted on this book, but overall, I feel it deserves 4 stars. First, the future mother-in-law. Yikes. The issue I had with her was that she was a little too like my own MIL, lol. Very condescending and patronizing to the female lead who got no back up from her fiancé. The flip side was that the fiancé was having trouble finding the middle ground between making everyone happy and reinforcing inappropriate behavior. I hate how realistic it was compared to my own relationship and was so, so relieved when he finally grew a backbone.

Second, the immaturity of the female lead was so annoying. How could she not see how hard her fiancé was trying with her? That is true love that he wouldn’t get fed up with her BS after all of that. He was a saint with that patience, though I will say he isn’t innocent, either. (That whole make her jealous until she’s about to cry stuff isn’t a good look.) I related to her in some ways, the rejections and not living up to the potential that you feel you have. She was so resentful of good intentions, though. I’m glad she worked through it, but it was hard to read through those parts. When the story began with Nicholas not getting along with her friends and she not getting along with his and then both of their families being what they were, I just didn’t “get it.” I didn’t understand how she could put her pride before her feelings. They were both so damn miserable, why stay that way for the sake of not being the one to end it? Petty and immature. Nicholas deserved better, IMO.

Lastly, and I’m glad this worked out before they got married but I’m annoyed it took so long for them to figure it out, they didn’t know each other! It’s so immature to get engaged without actually knowing what the other person wants in life. She hid so much from him about her aspirations. They were not on the same page about kids, though I think they actually were? But they hadn’t talked about it! She didn’t know so much about what he wanted either and when he tried to tell her, she laughed. Yikes!

Through all of that, though, I was happy with the book. I started it and didn’t put it down until I was done. I think things were ended properly. I was glad they did things on their terms in the end.