amu_pdf's profile picture

amu_pdf 's review for:

If He Had Been with Me by Laura Nowlin
1.0

This ending was so unbelievably stupid. To begin, the main character was honestly just annoying. I am by no means defending Jamie because he sucks, but he deserved better than Autumn. She didn’t even like him and was just irritating throughout the book. Here are spoilers for the ending:
It was the worst one I’ve ever read. It all happened on the last fifteen pages where Finn and Autumn finally got together. (I was not rooting for them btw, Finn deserves better.) Finn just dies in a car crash for absolutely no reason. And then she just tries to kill herself??? and says that she will continue to try until she is successful but then it's revealed that she is pregnant and she knows Finn wouldn’t be happy with her if she killed herself while pregnant with their kid???
It was all so stupid and out of nowhere and unnecessary. I hated it.