You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

3.0

Screams from the Dark is a hard one to review for me because the stories I liked, I liked a lot. But I did find myself skimming some of them, especially at the start -- the first few stories didn't really work for me, so I was disappointed to begin with. I had high expectations because I generally love Ellen Datlow's anthologies.

I liked the concept of the anthology and the variety of monsters. Many of the stories had a strong premise but writing didn't work for me: for example, Fran Wilde's The Midway was so, so cool (sea creature powering an amusement park, but it needs to be fed regularly) but the action was often hard to follow. Most of my favourite stories were by authors I already knew and loved. John Langan and Stephen Graham Jones were standouts, as always.

Because I did wind up skimming or starting stories and deciding not to finish them, I'm giving this one three stars. But some of the stories were closer to five stars, so I think it's absolutely worth picking up.