meilinnn's profile picture

meilinnn 's review for:

The Grace Year by Kim Liggett
3.0

3.5
The concept was really good and I read it so quickly. I appreciate the underlying message of this book - it’s important and I’m glad it’s being talked about. That being said, I feel like the execution could’ve been a lot better. I had to look up if I was reading a middle grade book bc that’s how the writing felt.

A lot of the writing was too on the nose for me. Clearly, this fictional county and their customs were meant to represent our society today as it pertains to how women are viewed. So when an author is trying to create this symbolism, but feels the need to explain it so directly to the readers, it means 1) ur not doing a good job at creating imagery 2) you don’t trust in your readers to be smart enough to understand the reference. Both piss me off.

Tierney was supposed to be portrayed as this tough girl but she fr was not giving that to me. At every pivotal moment, she flopped or was STUPID. Like wait … she was prepared to sacrifice herself when she got back and randomly didn’t? WEEN SHIT. She just let the town continue to live a lie…literally nothing changed like why did she change her mind?

wait I’m remembering now. Not this damn book trying to paint Michael as a good guy? He banished the 7 year old. Dafuq.
Also he’s giving such sloppy seconds like why did she settle for him. Not like I liked Ryker either but whatever

Also like..this book took a wild turn in the end. Romance? Pregnancy? No revolution at all? Felt like a cop out. did not like Kiersten. Idgaf about the poison - she was murderous before she drank that well water. Wait also that shit with Hans??? Hello???

Honestly felt like this writer had a lot of different ideas and tried to pile them into this book without developing them enough. I really cannot get behind the romance like wtf doesn’t make sense to me

Ok I know I’m being a hater so let me get to positives:
It was good. LOL. Like the concept was entertaining, the middle part was VERY entertaining, and I am glad that the girls found a sense of camaraderie at the end. Done